Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query..!
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query..!
Scanned Judgements…!
Integrated Development - The provided sources do not explicitly define integrated development as a standalone term. However, the concept is reflected through descriptions of planning and development activities that are coordinated and comprehensive within a specific area or project. For example, in the context of urban planning, integrated development involves conjoining various developmental activities such as physical, social, and economic planning to achieve cohesive growth. ["RAJALINGAM VS. COLOMBO MUNICIPAL COUNCIL"]
Main Points and Insights:
Legal and Administrative Context: The law emphasizes the importance of integrated planning in development authorities' functions, with specific powers to promote coordinated physical and economic development ["RAJALINGAM VS. COLOMBO MUNICIPAL COUNCIL"].
Analysis and Conclusion:
References:- ["Daryav Singh vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh - Madhya Pradesh"]- ["JAGDISH CHANDRA TAILOR Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN - Rajasthan"]- ["Kali Charan VS State Of U. P. - Supreme Court"]- ["RAJALINGAM VS. COLOMBO MUNICIPAL COUNCIL"]
In the world of property development, terms like integrated development often pop up in contracts, court cases, and regulatory discussions. But what exactly does it mean? If you've ever wondered, Can I have a definition of integrated development?, you're not alone. This question is particularly relevant for buyers, developers, and investors navigating Malaysia's property landscape, where mixed-use projects blend commercial and residential elements.
This blog post breaks down the concept based on legal precedents and statutory contexts, primarily under the Housing Development (Control and Licensing) Act 1966 (HDA). While no explicit statutory definition exists, courts and contracts provide clear guidance. Note: This is general information and not specific legal advice—consult a qualified lawyer for your situation.
No explicit statutory definition of integrated development appears in Malaysian legislation. However, it consistently describes mixed-use projects incorporating both commercial and residential components. This hybrid nature distinguishes them from purely residential developments, which fall squarely under HDA protections for housing accommodation. HO CHRISTOPHER WEN JINN vs BERJAYA TIMES SQUARE SDN BHD - 2011 MarsdenLR 1804
Key characteristics include:- Commercial parcels alongside residential units, potentially exempting commercial portions from HDA's housing-specific rules.- Emphasis on the project's predominant character (e.g., commercial vs. residential) to determine applicable laws.- Contractual framing as a proposed integrated commercial and/or residential development. COSMOPOLITAN AVENUE SDN BHD vs KHONG YAO HAN & ORS AND ANOTHER APPEAL - 2024 MarsdenLR 1401
Courts assess the project's overall makeup to apply the right regulatory regime, ensuring residential buyers get protections while commercial ones follow contract terms.
In HDA disputes, integrated development refers to projects blending commercial and residential elements. Commercial parcels typically do not qualify as housing accommodation under the HDA. For instance, in a notable case, a plaintiff purchasing a commercial parcel in such a development challenged administrative charges, arguing HDA applicability. The court clarified: Commercial premises do not qualify as housing accommodation under the Housing Development Act, and parties must adhere to contract stipulations unless unconscionable circumstances exist.HO CHRISTOPHER WEN JINN vs BERJAYA TIMES SQUARE SDN BHD - 2011 MarsdenLR 1804
This ruling implies that integrated developments may be deemed predominantly commercial, altering regulatory oversight. Residential units remain protected, but commercial areas escape certain HDA mandates.
SPAs often define the term explicitly. One example states: Project means the proposed integrated commercial and/or residential development...known as EMPIRE CITY @ DAMANSARA.COSMOPOLITAN AVENUE SDN BHD vs KHONG YAO HAN & ORS AND ANOTHER APPEAL - 2024 MarsdenLR 1401 This highlights the hybrid setup, with vacant possession terms applying differently: Such possession shall not give the Purchaser the right to occupy the Parcel and the Purchaser shall not occupy the Parcel until such time as the Certificate of Completion and Compliance of the Parcel is issued.COSMOPOLITAN AVENUE SDN BHD vs KHONG YAO HAN & ORS AND ANOTHER APPEAL - 2024 MarsdenLR 1401
Here, integrated equates to combined commercial/residential use, separating individual parcels from the broader project.
The documents contrast integrated developments with pure housing projects, excluding commercial elements from HDA protections. A related term, mixed development project, appears similarly: Common property in a mixed development project.PJ CENTRESTAGE JMB vs CHERISH SPRINGS SDN BHD & ORS - 2024 MarsdenLR 4365 Though not identical, it reinforces the hybrid theme.
Drawing from international parallels, Indian cases offer contextual insights. For example, under Chhattisgarh Bhumi Vikas Rules, modifications to development plans become an integrated part of the revised Development Plan, emphasizing seamless urban integration. Sanjay Bajpai Builders Pvt. Ltd. VS State of Chhattisgarh, through the Secretary, Department of Housing & Environment - 2017 Supreme(Chh) 176 In land acquisition matters, urgency for continuous integrated development alongside infrastructure like roads and electricity underscores planned growth. DEVENDRA KUMAR VS STATE OF U. P. - 2011 Supreme(All) 1413 These align with Malaysia's focus on mixed-use efficiency, preventing fragmented land use.
Another perspective from urban planning stresses: An integrated development will mean protecting the residential or commercial area. There cannot be a combustion and explosion of putting all the people into one compacted area.Md. Mustaque VS State Of Bihar - 2004 Supreme(Pat) 696 This highlights integrated approaches to avoid over-concentration, promoting sustainable habitats.
While integrated developments offer flexibility, caveats apply:- Predominant Character Rules: If commercial elements dominate, housing regulations may not apply fully, but residential units retain protections. HO CHRISTOPHER WEN JINN vs BERJAYA TIMES SQUARE SDN BHD - 2011 MarsdenLR 1804- Scope Limitations: Analysis focuses on housing-commercial hybrids; purely commercial or non-urban projects are unaddressed.- Contract Supremacy: SPAs govern details, but courts prioritize statutory intent for residential purchaser safeguards.
In water resource disputes, integrated development contrasts with independent allocations, showing its versatility across sectors. State Of Haryana VS State Of Punjab - 2002 1 Supreme 141
For developers and buyers:- Classify Early: Determine predominant use to gauge HDA applicability.- Review SPAs Thoroughly: Check for integrated definitions and parcel-specific terms.- Dispute Strategy: Argue parcel nature (e.g., commercial exclusion) while referencing project descriptions. COSMOPOLITAN AVENUE SDN BHD vs KHONG YAO HAN & ORS AND ANOTHER APPEAL - 2024 MarsdenLR 1401HO CHRISTOPHER WEN JINN vs BERJAYA TIMES SQUARE SDN BHD - 2011 MarsdenLR 1804
In practice, integrated projects foster vibrant communities but require careful navigation of regs. For instance, planned industrial integrations demand urgency to support infrastructure continuity. DEVENDRA KUMAR VS STATE OF U. P. - 2011 Supreme(All) 1413
Integrated developments drive modern urban growth, balancing commerce and living spaces. As Malaysia's property market evolves, understanding this term empowers informed decisions. Always consult legal experts for tailored advice.
References:1. HO CHRISTOPHER WEN JINN vs BERJAYA TIMES SQUARE SDN BHD - 2011 MarsdenLR 1804: Commercial exemption in integrated developments.2. COSMOPOLITAN AVENUE SDN BHD vs KHONG YAO HAN & ORS AND ANOTHER APPEAL - 2024 MarsdenLR 1401: SPA definition of integrated project.3. PJ CENTRESTAGE JMB vs CHERISH SPRINGS SDN BHD & ORS - 2024 MarsdenLR 4365: Mixed development context.4. Additional insights from Sanjay Bajpai Builders Pvt. Ltd. VS State of Chhattisgarh, through the Secretary, Department of Housing & Environment - 2017 Supreme(Chh) 176, DEVENDRA KUMAR VS STATE OF U. P. - 2011 Supreme(All) 1413, Md. Mustaque VS State Of Bihar - 2004 Supreme(Pat) 696, State Of Haryana VS State Of Punjab - 2002 1 Supreme 141.
#IntegratedDevelopment #MalaysiaPropertyLaw #RealEstateLegal
Soil will fall within the defination of mineral under section 247(7) of M.P Land Revenue Code. Mineral and Minor Mineral is given in Mines and Mineral (Development & Regulation) 1957. ... As per section 3(e), building stones, gravel, ordinary clay, ordinary sand and sand also fall within the defination of minor mineral. There is report by Surveyor that five trolleys of soil has been found which has been extracted.
The respondents also claimed that as per the scheme, a minimum of 10 hectares of land must be available as a single piece in order to qualify for development of Integrated Township. ... If the petitioner’s original integrated scheme of 2008 and the integrated scheme of 2018 are considered together, the total area exceeds 27.91 hectares, which is well above the 10 hectares which is minimum required for any residential integrated township scheme. ... 18) The facts which are not seriously in dispute are....
• Yes, the present acquisition forms part of the integrated development plan for the Yamuna Expressway initiated by YEIDA. ... Hence, the project did not contemplate a planned and integrated development of an Expressway and the adjoining areas. It was a standalone project pertaining to the development in industrial Gautam Budh Nagar. ... The construction of the Jewar Airport is also a part and parcel of the very same integrated project. (ii) That a bare perusal of the Master Plan(Phas....
The defination of deficiency is defined in section 2(g) of the Consumer Protection Act. ... When the aforesaid premium amount was accepted by opp. party No. 2 he was in the employment of opp. party No. 1 as Development Officer at Opera House Branch. Thus, it is clear that opp. party No. 2 was acting in the discharge of his official functions for opp. party No. 1. ... Considering the wider amplitude of defination of service, in repudiating the complainants claim after accepting the proposal and premium amount, clearly amounts the deficienc....
It is also required to refer to defination of election as defined in Section 2(1)(d) of the Act which as under :- Section 2(1) in The a href="./.. ... The factual aspects in the present case is where Taluka Panchayat election was undertaken, would not fall within the defination of the election defined in the Act. Thus, there is no reason to attract the offence under a href="./.. ... He would further submit that Taluka Panchayat, does not fall within the defination of election within Section 2 (1) (d) of the Act. 5. ... Learned APP could....
show that she is not covered by either of the four exceptions to the defination. ... Thus, in order to succeed, the appellant is not only required to prove that she is not covered by either of the four exceptions to the defination, but she falls within one of the stipulated categories in the first part of the defination. ... The interpretation of Section 2 (s) must be such as would not lead to stultifying innovation, development and change in managerial practice. Business managers should have a high degree of latitude to....
(tenant) starts a business after taking the same on lease, then the said #3# running factory doing business and if a running factory business is leased out by a landlord to a tenant, then it does not fall within the defination
There is no separate defination of the expression "perquisite" for the purpose of this section. The defination in s. 17 (2) is does not include a cash payment such as "bonus" paid. ... Explanation 2 to s. 40a (5) and clause (a) of the Explanation, inter alia states that the defination of salary as given in s. 17 is assigned with a modification that the word "perquisite" occurring in sub-clause (iv) and the whole sub-clause (vii) shall be omitted.
... The enumeration of articles like wearing apparel, jewellery, and furniture mentioned by way of illustration in the above-quoted defination of "personal effects" also shows that the legislature intended only those articles to be included in the defination, which were intimately ... According to this defination, as it stood in the year of assessment, "capital asset" means property of any kind help by an assessee whether or not connected with his business or profession, but does not include... personal effects, that if to say, movable pr....
, which by law are required to be consistent with aforesaid integrated planning. ... The primary purpose of this section can be seen as conferring necessary powers on the UDA to carry out, integrated planning and physical development within and among 'development areas' subject to any directions that may be given to the Authority by the Minister from time to time. ... Moreover, when considering the scheme of section 8 of the UDA Law, one can observe that the powers and functions assigned to the UDA by the Law rev....
24. Section 23-A of the Adhiniyam, 1973 provides that the State Government, on its own motion or on the request of Development Authority, make modification in the Development Plan for urgent public purpose. The modification so made in the Development Plan shall be an integrated part of the revised Development Plan.
In case of delay there may be encroachments over the land. The prominent industrialists of the country, who wish to invest their capital in UP, have to be provided with land urgently. The land is also needed for continuity of infrastructural services and all round development like roads, sewerage, provision of electricity and its distribution for development. The land is needed for a continuous integrated development along with the development of the neighbouring land acquired earlier.
A pressured habitat calls for moving into a fresh new found land use for yet further habitation. Constriction of land use will be an antithesis of planning. An integrated development will mean protecting the residential or commercial area. There cannot be a combustion and explosion of putting all the people into one compacted area.
According to the learned counsel, integrated development is distinct from independent allocation of share of water and this being the position, the entire basis on which the State of Haryana has filed the suit for completion of the SYL Canal falls through. Dr. Dhawan also went to the extent of arguing that an order passed by the Central Government under Section 78 of the Reorganisation Act being outside the scope of the Act itself, must be read down to make it legal and the only way the same has to be read down is that the order is an Executive order, not enforceable being beyond the scope ....
The learned counsel also contended that non-mention of the Thien (now Ranjit Sagar) Dam or Madhopur Beas Link, is sufficient to indicate that those projects are to serve different purposes between different states and the same cannot be brought by implication since some aspects of it have been mentioned in the Beas Project. Dr Dhavan also went to the extent of arguing that an order passed by the Central Government under Section 78 of the Reorganisation act being outside the scope of the Act itself, must be read down to make it legal and the only way the same has to be read down is that the o....
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
