Justice Hima Kohli Judgments: Chronological List

Justice Hima Kohli is a distinguished jurist who has served on the Supreme Court of India and previously as a judge of the Delhi High Court. Her judgments span a wide array of legal domains, including industrial disputes, election petitions, civil procedure, property law, and constitutional matters. For legal professionals, researchers, and those interested in Indian jurisprudence, understanding her contributions in chronological order provides valuable context on evolving legal interpretations.

A common query in legal circles is: Give me a Judgement Delivered by Justice Hima Kohli in Chronological Order. This blog post compiles a comprehensive list based on available records, integrating details from Supreme Court and Delhi High Court cases. Note that this is general information for educational purposes and not specific legal advice. Always consult a qualified lawyer for case-specific guidance.

Overview of Justice Hima Kohli's Judicial Tenure

Appointed to the Supreme Court in 2021, Justice Kohli brought extensive experience from her time at the Delhi High Court (2007-2016). Her rulings often emphasize procedural fairness, compliance with statutory notices, and practical resolution of disputes. Key themes include:- Enforcement of labor awards and deposits in industrial cases.- Interpretation of civil procedure rules for amendments and counter-claims.- Tenancy terminations and possession decrees.- Election petition admissions and limitations.

This chronological compilation draws from documented cases, highlighting oral and written judgments alike. Dates are approximated where explicit; many Delhi High Court matters from 2014-2017 precede her Supreme Court phase (post-2021).

Chronological List of Key Judgments

Early Delhi High Court Judgments (2011-2017)

1. SMT. SHIRAMABAI vs THE CAPTAIN RECORD OFFICER FOR O. I. C. RECORDS_SC_35509_2011 (Heard 02-06-2022, Vacation Bench with Justice B.R. Gavai)

   UTTAM vs THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

2. Involved appellants represented by Mr. Rohan Thanwani. Justice Kohli participated in the vacation bench proceedings. This case underscores her involvement in urgent appellate matters.

3. 2015 0 Supreme(Del) 2373 (Civil Procedure - Limitation and Affidavit Defects) 2015 0 Supreme(Del) 2373

4. Ruling: The defects pointed out by the Registry were mere irregularities capable of being cured and did not invalidate the suit. The plaintiff's affidavit was furnished at the time of re-filing, curing the original defects. 2015 0 Supreme(Del) 2373

5. A suit for damages against IIT Delhi was upheld, rejecting limitation pleas. The court deemed the suit presented on its first filing date.

6. 2015 0 Supreme(Del) 3237 (CPC Order 6 Rule 17 - Amendment and Counter-Claim) 2015 0 Supreme(Del) 3237

7. Key Holding: Once the right of the defendant to file the written statement has expired, then a counter claim cannot be filed... Permitting the defendant to plead a counter claim by way of the proposed amendment would not result in prolonging the trial. 2015 0 Supreme(Del) 3237

8. Allowed amendment for a counter-claim of Rs. 11,23,310/- to avoid multiplicity of proceedings.

9. 2015 0 Supreme(Del) 4388 (CPC Order XII Rule 6 - Possession Decree) 2015 0 Supreme(Del) 4388

10. Judgment Excerpt: Defendant's tenancy had been validly terminated by the plaintiff/Trust upon issuance of the legal notice... suit for the relief of possession is decreed. 2015 0 Supreme(Del) 4388

11. Decreed possession for a trust against a tenant based on admissions, bypassing full trial.

12. 2017 0 Supreme(Del) 1174 (Representation of the People Act - Election Petition) 2017 0 Supreme(Del) 1174

13. Dismissed judgment on admissions; required full trial for election invalidation due to degree misrepresentation.

14. 2018 0 Supreme(Del) 397 (Security Deposit Refund - Contract Clauses) 2018 0 Supreme(Del) 397

15. Ratio: The security deposit is liable to be refunded upon the compliance of the conditions in Clauses 17 and 45... Interest would be payable on delayed payments. 2018 0 Supreme(Del) 397

16. Directed North DMC to refund with 12% interest if delayed.

17. Shanti Devi vs Union of India

    (Oral Judgment)

    Shanti Devi vs Union of India

18. Hima Kohli, J. (Oral). Part of early Delhi High Court oral orders.

Subsequent oral judgments in 201X series:

Virender Rastogi vs Brij Mohan Juneja

Shanti Devi vs Union of India

Virender Rastogi vs Brij Mohan Juneja

Ram Vilas vs Vice Chairman, Delhi Development Authority

Rati Ram vs Delhi Development Authority

Shahroz Raza vs Jamia Millia Islamia

Mumtaz vs Chairman, Delhi Development Authority

Ganga Prasad vs Delhi Development Authority

Rajni Rani vs Delhi Development Authority

Kishore Singh vs Govt. of NCT

Asha Gupta vs BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd.

Johri Lal Jain vs Municipal Corporation of Delhi

Jagriti Mahila Samiti vs Raj Nischal

Araav Porwal vs Mother International School

Rita Bhutani vs N.D.M.C.

Vimla Sharma vs Municipal Corporation of Delhi

Rajinder Singh vs Commissioner of Police

Shantanu Kadam vs National Board of Examinations

Supreme Court Era (2014-2024)

1. SMT. SHIRAMABAI vs THE CAPTAIN RECORD OFFICER FOR O. I. C. RECORDS_SC_7044_2014SMT. SHIRAMABAI vs THE CAPTAIN RECORD OFFICER FOR O. I. C. RECORDS_SC_7044_2014

2. HIMA KOHLI, J. Early Supreme Court involvement.

3. SMT. SHIRAMABAI vs THE CAPTAIN RECORD OFFICER FOR O. I. C. RECORDS_SC_33004_2018 (Leave Granted)

   SMT. SHIRAMABAI vs THE CAPTAIN RECORD OFFICER FOR O. I. C. RECORDS_SC_33004_2018

4. Procedural grant of leave.

5. SMT. SHIRAMABAI vs THE CAPTAIN RECORD OFFICER FOR O. I. C. RECORDS_SC_3275_2019 (Leave Granted)

   SMT. SHIRAMABAI vs THE CAPTAIN RECORD OFFICER FOR O. I. C. RECORDS_SC_3275_2019
   • Similar procedural note.

Recent Supreme Court cases (2023-2024):

1. 2023 Supreme(Online)(SC) 8979 (Industrial Disputes Act) 2023 Supreme(Online)(SC) 8979

   • Excerpt: The operation of a judgment must be complied with unless specifically stayed... Appellant instructed to deposit amounts. 2023 Supreme(Online)(SC) 8979
   • Ordered deposit with 7% interest; emphasized compliance unless stayed.

2. 2024 Supreme(Online)(SC) 5012 (03-04-2024) 2024 Supreme(Online)(SC) 5012

   • With Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah; disposed appeals.

3. 2024 Supreme(Online)(SC) 2049 (12-03-2024) 2024 Supreme(Online)(SC) 2049

   • Petitioners represented by Mr. Rajiv Shankar Dvivedi; procedural.

4. 2024 Supreme(Online)(SC) 9362024 Supreme(Online)(SC) 936

   • Exemption applications granted.

5. 2023 Supreme(Online)(SC) 36262023 Supreme(Online)(SC) 3626

   • Intra-court appeals allowed.

6. 2023 Supreme(Online)(SC) 19714 (06-10-2023) 2023 Supreme(Online)(SC) 19714

   • Note: The court declined to interfere with the High Court's orders while leaving important legal questions open. 2023 Supreme(Online)(SC) 19714
   • Dismissed SLPs, questions open.

Summary of Findings and Themes

• Span: From 2011 Delhi High Court to 2024 Supreme Court, covering ~50+ cases, many oral SMT. SHIRAMABAI vs THE CAPTAIN RECORD OFFICER FOR O. I. C. RECORDS

  Rita Bhutani vs N.D.M.C.

• Formats: Mix of written, oral, with leave grants in appeals.
• Recurring Motifs:
• Procedural Leniency: Amendments allowed if no delay (e.g., counter-claims) 2015 0 Supreme(Del) 3237
• Compliance Emphasis: Judgments operative unless stayed 2023 Supreme(Online)(SC) 8979
• Efficiency: Decrees on admissions to avoid trials 2015 0 Supreme(Del) 4388

Sources indicate Delhi cases (011 prefix) dominate early phase, transitioning to Supreme Court (INDSC).

Recommendations for Further Research

• Review full texts via official portals like SCI website or Delhi HC.
• Analyze clusters: Labor (Industrial Disputes), Civil (CPC), Electoral.

Key Takeaways

Justice Hima Kohli's judgments exemplify balanced, pragmatic jurisprudence, prioritizing justice without undue procedural hurdles. This list aids quick reference but is not exhaustive—legal landscapes evolve. For personalized advice, engage a legal expert.

This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.