Whether a Revision Petition Lies Against an Order Passed After Hearing Both Sides
Courts frequently grant ad interim injunctions at the very first hearing of a suit, sometimes after briefly hearing both parties, and litigants often rush to the revisional forum to challenge such orders. A recurring question therefore arises: is a revision petition maintainable against an order of passed after hearing the parties? The consistent answer across High Courts is generally no — an ad interim order is an interlocutory measure, not a decided case, and revision does not ordinarily lie against it.
Why Ad Interim Orders Are Not Revisable
The controlling principle is that revisional jurisdiction can be exercised only against a or a final order on an interim application. An , whether granted ex parte or after hearing both sides, does not finally determine the rights of the parties. It is a transient arrangement that remains subject to further consideration by the trial court itself.
The has held authoritatively that no revision lies before the Board of Revenue under , against any ex parte or ad interim order of a trial or appellate court. The court reasoned:
Since at the stage of ad-interim order, the application for interim injunction is not decided, therefore, the revision is not maintainable. 2025 0 Supreme(Raj) 2255
The fact that both parties were heard before the ad interim order was passed does not change its character. Unless the interim application itself has been finally disposed of — for instance, by confirming or vacating the after contest — the order remains interlocutory. The has applied the same logic under the , observing that against an passed in an interim injunction application, revision is not maintainable. 2025 Supreme(Online)(All) 2482
This position echoes earlier rulings such as those noting that an order does not come in the category of hence no revision is maintainable against such order. 2008 0 Supreme(Raj) 928 The has similarly recognised that though against an order of normally, a revision will not lie, the aggrieved party ought to approach the court below or the appellate forum instead. 2011 0 Supreme(Mad) 2476 In election disputes under the , courts have also held that a civil revision petition under was not the appropriate remedy at the stage of an ad interim order. 2010 0 Supreme(Mad) 1972
The Correct Remedies for an Aggrieved Party
Rather than filing a revision, a party aggrieved by an typically has three avenues:
- Application to — Move the same court under , seeking vacation or modification of the ad interim order. This is usually the quickest and most direct remedy.
- Appeal under — Orders under are generally appealable under Order 43, Rule 1(r). However, the appellate court hearing an appeal from an is not competent to decide the injunction petition itself on merits; as the observed, doing so would in effect amount to a consideration of the petition on merits. 1992 0 Supreme(Ker) 53
- Revisional or supervisory intervention in exceptional cases — Only where the order suffers from , , or total lack of jurisdiction may extraordinary forums be invoked.
The in clarified that a party aggrieved by an ex parte interim order may either move the appellate court or approach the same court, and cannot approach the appellate or revisional Court during the pendency of the application for grant or vacation of . 2008 0 Supreme(Mad) 3962
When the Position Changes: Final Orders and Jurisdictional Errors
The interlocutory-versus-final distinction is decisive. The has held that where the injunction application remains pending before the trial court, a revision challenging the interim arrangement is maintainable precisely because no appeal would yet lie — Unless and until the order passed by the learned Trial Judge finally disposes of the injunction application, an appeal would not be maintainable... the revision is maintainable. 2025 0 Supreme(Mad) 3840 Conversely, once the interim application is finally decided, the proper remedy shifts to appeal.
Courts have also carved out limited exceptions for jurisdictional defects. Where a trial court passes an order wholly without jurisdiction — for example, in a guardianship matter before a court lacking territorial competence — Article 227 supervision may be available. 1998 0 Supreme(Mad) 195 Similarly, where a trial court fails to record reasons for refusing to extend an interim injunction or ignores the merits altogether, the has corrected such a docket order under Article 227, treating it as a fundamental irregularity. 2024 0 Supreme(Mad) 2292
The has likewise noted that supervisory powers under can be sparingly exercised only in rare cases where a in apparent disregard to a specific mandatory legal provision has occurred, or where a has resulted. 2025 0 Supreme(Raj) 108
Procedural compliance also matters. If the court below grants an without recording reasons as mandated by , some courts have observed that the defect may affect the availability of the appellate remedy itself, complicating the question of which forum the aggrieved party may approach. 2025 Supreme(Online)(Tel) 26030
Practical Takeaways
- An — even one passed after hearing both parties — is generally interlocutory and not revisable.
- The critical test is whether the interim application has been finally decided; only then does the order typically become appealable or revisable.
- The primary remedy is an application under Order 39, Rule 4 CPC to the order, or an appeal under where maintainable.
- Extraordinary remedies under Article 227 or statutory revisional powers are reserved for , , or want of jurisdiction.
Litigants facing an adverse should therefore act swiftly before the trial court itself, reserving revisional and constitutional remedies for genuinely exceptional situations. Since procedural rules vary across statutes and states, parties may wish to verify the specific remedy available in their case with counsel before choosing a forum.
#InjunctionLaw #CivilRevision #InterimOrders #CodeOfCivilProcedure #Litigation