SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2011 Supreme(Mad) 2476

2011 (2) MWN(Civil) 732
High Court of Judicature at Madras
R.S. RAMANATHAN
P.R. Dhanasundari @ Rajeshwari & Others
Versus
M. Sugumar Reddy & Another
C.R.P.(PD) No.2791 of 2010 & M.P.Nos.1 & 2 of 2010
Decided On: 29-04-2011

Important Points

The main legal point established is that while granting ex parte interim injunction, the court must consider various factors and record reasons for the grant, as required by Order XXXIX Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Subject

Civil Law - Injunctions

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.39 R.3(a)
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.227

Headnote

Injunction - Civil Procedure - Order XXXIX Rule 3

Fact of the Case:

The plaintiff filed a suit for permanent injunction against the defendants. The court granted ad interim injunction in favor of the plaintiff, which was challenged by the defendants in a revision petition.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the ad interim injunction was granted after considering the facts and documents presented by the plaintiff, and therefore, the order was not passed without application of mind and without stating the reasons.

Issues: The main issue was whether the court's grant of ad interim injunction was in contravention of the provisions of Order XXXIX Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Ratio Decidendi: The court emphasized the necessity to record reasons for granting ex parte injunction, as required by Order XXXIX Rule 3. It held that the court must consider various factors such as prima facie case, balance of convenience, and irreparable injury, and state the reasons for granting ad interim injunction to enable the party to understand the reasons for it.

Final Decision: The civil revision petition was dismissed, and it was held that no exceptional case had been brought out to invoke Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

Advocates Appeared:
For the Petitioners:Mr. S. Parthasarathy, Senior Counsel, for Mr. K. Govi Ganesan, Advocate.
For the Respondents:R1, Mr. P. Subba Reddy, Advocate.

Judgment :-

1. Defendants 1 to 4 in O.S.No.157 of 2010 on the file of the Principal District Judge, Chingleput, who are respondents 1 to 4 in I.A.No.661 of 2010, filed the revision against the order passed by the Principal District Judge granting ad interim injunction in the above suit.

2. The first respondent/plaintiff filed the above suit for permanent injunction restraining the revision petitioners from interfering with their possession and enjoyment of the property and for direction. Alongwith the suit, the respondent filed 22 documents and the learned Principal District Judge, after hearing the respondent/plaintiff, passed the following order on 30.7.2010 which is challenged in this revision:-

"Heard both sides.

The partnership firm has been registered in the name and style of M/s.South India Engineering Works. Wherein the partners in the firm are 1)Thiru.A.C.Nataraja Mudaliar and 2)Thiru.A.V.Manoharan. Each one is having 50% right in the firm.

The firm bought the suit property in the firm's name and holding and enjoying the property. After that in between two partners on 22.5.1971 Dissolution Deed has been made and as per Dissolution Deed Thiru.A.V.Manoharan retired from the firm and the burden shifted to another party Thiru.A.C.Nataraja Mudaliar automatically and the entire assets and liabilities were taken over by Thiru.A.C.Nataraja Mudaliar for a consideration of Rs.5000/-. Document NO.1 is the Dissolution of partnership firm. Document NO.2 is the General Power of Attorney dated 30.1.1991 given to Thiru.Umakanthan to sell the property. Document No.3 is the Death Certificate of Thriu.A.C.Nataraja Mudaliar. Document No.4 is the Sale Deed in favour of Thiru.S.Ratnasamy dated 19.8.1994. Document No.5 is the Sale deed dated 4.7.1995 in favour of Tmt.Dhanam Ramasamy. Document No.6 is the Sale deed dated 4.7.1995 in favour of Thiru.Ramasamy. Further, Dhanam Ramasamy sold the same property in the year 2007 to the plaintiff i.e.,

Document Nos.7 to 13. Patta, Chitta, Adangals, i.e., Document No.16 stands in the name of the plaintiff. Document NO.18 is the Sale Deed executed by Thiru.A.V.Manoharan (D5) in favour of Defendants 1 to 4. On perusal of the documents it shows that the plaintiff purchased the property from one Tmt.Dhanam Ramasamy in the year 2007 by way of documents 7 to 13. For that, patta also transferred in the name of the plaintiff by way of document No.16. Therefore, prima facie case is made out. Balance of convenience is also in favour of the plaintiff and the plaintiff is in possession and enjoyment of the suit property. Ad-Interim injunction is granted till 12.8.2010. Notice to Respondents by then. Order 39 Rule 3(a) to be complied with."

3. Heard both sides. Mr.S.Parthasarathy, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners submitted that though against an order of ad interim injunction normally, a revision will not lie and the revision petitioners ought to have approached the court below and if any temporary injunction is granted, they ought to have filed appeal before the first appellate court, having regard to the nature of the order passed by the Principal District Judge, the revision is maintainable against the ad interim injunction order granted by the court below. The learned Senior Counsel submitted that as per Order XXXIX Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure, when the court proposed to grant an injunction without giving notice of the application to the opposite party, the court shall record the reasons for its opinion that the object of granting interim injunction would be defeated by delay and therefore, while granting ad interim injunction without giving notice to the other party, the court ought to have stated in the order in specific terms that if injunction is not granted, the object of granting the same would be defeated, while recording the reasons and in this case, the court below has not stated as to how the object of grant of injunction would be defeated by delay and therefore, there is violation of m


























































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top