Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query..!
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query..!
Scanned Judgements…!
The society's decision to admit or refuse a member should be communicated within a specified period, and refusal must be justified with reasons ["Brightland Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. vs Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-op. Societies, Mumbai Division - Bombay"].
Analysis and Conclusion:
References:- ["GIRISH SAHAKARI GRIHRACHANA THROUGH CHANDRASHEKHAR BHAGWAT DESHPANDE CHAIRMAN AND SECRETARY vs MALLIKARJUN MADHAVRAO NAVANDE AND ORS - Bombay"]- ["Rishi Garg VS State of Haryana - Punjab and Haryana"]- ["Foreshore Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. vs Divisional Joint Registrar of Cooperative Societies - Bombay"]- ["Tanvi’s Diamoda Cooperative Housing Society Ltd. vs State of Maharashtra, Office of Ld. Government Pleader - Bombay"]- ["Brightland Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. vs Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-op. Societies, Mumbai Division - Bombay"]
Joining a cooperative society, especially in housing complexes, is a significant step for many residents in India. But what exactly are the criteria for subscription for a member in a society? If you're a prospective member, tenant, or current resident facing membership disputes, understanding these rules is crucial. Governed primarily by the society's bye-laws and statutes like the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960, eligibility isn't automatic—it involves specific personal, financial, and procedural hurdles.
This guide breaks down the eligibility requirements, decision-making processes, judicial interpretations, and practical tips. Note: This is general information based on legal precedents and should not be considered specific legal advice. Consult a qualified lawyer for your situation.
Society membership eligibility is primarily governed by the society’s by-laws, which outline detailed criteria applicants must meet. These typically include:
These conditions ensure only suitable candidates join, preserving the society's integrity. As one ruling notes, The applicant shall be deemed to have been admitted as a member of such society only after fulfilling these and gaining approval—tenant status alone doesn't confer rights without compliance. Uday Dalal vs Divisional Joint Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Mumbai - 2025 Supreme(Bom) 1455
Admission or removal isn't unilateral. The managing committee typically reviews applications, requiring approval from more than half its members, but ultimate authority often lies with the General Body. Shantiniketan Cooperative Housing Society Ltd. through its Chairman VS Shivkant, the Assistant Registrar and the Divisional Joint Registrar - 2013 0 Supreme(Bom) 2657SWARAJ SONI VS REHABILITATION MINISTRY EMPLOYEES CO-OPERATIVE HOUSEBUILDING SOCIETY LIMITED - 1990 0 Supreme(Del) 157
Courts have clarified: The decision to admit or remove a member rested with the General Body of the Society, not the managing committee. The committee can't remove members without General Body action and a hearing opportunity. SWARAJ SONI VS REHABILITATION MINISTRY EMPLOYEES CO-OPERATIVE HOUSEBUILDING SOCIETY LIMITED - 1990 0 Supreme(Del) 157
In disputes, external bodies like the Registrar have limited roles. For instance, This provision deals with eligibility criteria. It does not deal with adjudication of disputes regarding illegal entries. It does not authorise the Registrar to create membership or substitute one member for another. Namdeo Suratsingh Chaudhary vs Natu Ambersingh Patil (Deceased) - 2025 Supreme(Bom) 1865 The society's governing bodies hold primacy, respecting procedural fairness.
Indian courts consistently emphasize bye-law supremacy. In a notable case, a long-time member (since 1971) was entitled to be heard before membership decisions, underscoring natural justice. SWARAJ SONI VS REHABILITATION MINISTRY EMPLOYEES CO-OPERATIVE HOUSEBUILDING SOCIETY LIMITED - 1990 0 Supreme(Del) 157
Membership doesn't arise merely from tenancy: Membership in cooperative societies requires compliance with specified contributions and procedures; lacking compliance, tenant status does not automatically confer membership rights. Uday Dalal vs Divisional Joint Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Mumbai - 2025 Supreme(Bom) 1455 The predecessor-in-title must meet criteria, and societies must decide admissions. Uday Dalal vs Divisional Joint Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Mumbai - 2025 Supreme(Bom) 1455
Another ruling reinforces: The court held that enduring tenant status does not guarantee membership without contributing and emphasized the hierarchy of authority in decision-making for societies. Joint Registrars can't override society decisions on admissions. Uday Dalal vs Divisional Joint Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Mumbai - 2025 Supreme(Bom) 1455
Bye-law amendments restricting eligibility are valid if properly enacted, and ineligible parties lack locus standi to challenge them. Admittedly, the plaintiffs have not claimed any declaratory relief that they are eligible to become the members of the defendant Society. Palani Town Viswa Brahmana Mahajana Sangam (REGD,7/1958) VS P. Thangavel - 2024 Supreme(Mad) 1054
For disqualifications, the moment a member of a society becomes ineligible to be a member of the society, that person is liable to be expelled from membership. The Registrar may declare cessation, but societies must follow procedures. Part-Time Administrator Adat Farmers Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. and Another v. Vipin K. Hari - 2022 Supreme(Online)(Ker) 63626
While bye-laws set the rules, exceptions include:- Hearing Rights: Members must get a fair chance before adverse actions. SWARAJ SONI VS REHABILITATION MINISTRY EMPLOYEES CO-OPERATIVE HOUSEBUILDING SOCIETY LIMITED - 1990 0 Supreme(Del) 157- No Arbitrary Rejections: Decisions require full criteria assessment; challenges succeed if flawed. SWARAJ SONI VS REHABILITATION MINISTRY EMPLOYEES CO-OPERATIVE HOUSEBUILDING SOCIETY LIMITED - 1990 0 Supreme(Del) 157- Registrar's Limits: Can't force admissions or ignore bye-laws. Haryana cases echo this: Societies must follow model bye-laws scrupulously. Alaknanda Cooperative Group Housing Society Ltd. VS Financial Commissioner, Cooperation and Principal Secretary to Govt. Haryana - 2016 Supreme(P&H) 1134
Tenant-to-member transitions fail without contributions: Rights evolve over time, prioritizing existing members. Uday Dalal vs Divisional Joint Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Mumbai - 2025 Supreme(Bom) 1455
Societies can't expel without due process; appeals to Registrars need evidence of expulsion. Alaknanda Cooperative Group Housing Society Ltd. VS Financial Commissioner, Cooperation and Principal Secretary to Govt. Haryana - 2016 Supreme(P&H) 1134
As per precedents, Society authorities should ensure that decisions regarding membership are based on a thorough assessment of all relevant criteria and that members are provided an opportunity to be heard. SWARAJ SONI VS REHABILITATION MINISTRY EMPLOYEES CO-OPERATIVE HOUSEBUILDING SOCIETY LIMITED - 1990 0 Supreme(Del) 157
Understanding these criteria empowers you in housing society matters. For tailored advice, reach out to a legal expert familiar with cooperative laws in your state.
References:1. Shantiniketan Cooperative Housing Society Ltd. through its Chairman VS Shivkant, the Assistant Registrar and the Divisional Joint Registrar - 2013 0 Supreme(Bom) 2657: Comprehensive eligibility details.2. SWARAJ SONI VS REHABILITATION MINISTRY EMPLOYEES CO-OPERATIVE HOUSEBUILDING SOCIETY LIMITED - 1990 0 Supreme(Del) 157: Authority and fairness in decisions.3. Uday Dalal vs Divisional Joint Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Mumbai - 2025 Supreme(Bom) 1455: Tenant vs. member distinctions.4. Namdeo Suratsingh Chaudhary vs Natu Ambersingh Patil (Deceased) - 2025 Supreme(Bom) 1865: Registrar limitations.5. Palani Town Viswa Brahmana Mahajana Sangam (REGD,7/1958) VS P. Thangavel - 2024 Supreme(Mad) 1054: Bye-law challenges and locus standi.6. Part-Time Administrator Adat Farmers Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. and Another v. Vipin K. Hari - 2022 Supreme(Online)(Ker) 63626: Disqualification and expulsion.
#SocietyMembership, #CoopSocietyLaws, #MembershipEligibility
, whereby respondent no. 1 has been directed to be admitted as a member of the society. ... Section 23 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 confers upon an eligible person a statutory right to seek admission as a member of a co-operative society. ... According to the petitioner, respondent no. 1, alleging refusal on the part of the society to admit him as a member, approached respondent no. 2 on 06 July 2015 by invoking Section 23(2) of the Act. ... Where an applicant fu....
Section 2 (XV) of the HRRS Act defines 'member' and lays down that a member means a person who fulfils the eligibility criteria for becoming a member of the society, as specified in the Act and has been admitted as a member of the society in accordance with its Bye laws. ... A donation shall not create a right in the donor to be admitted as a member of the society." ... time donated to the Society Rs. 11000/- in ca....
This preserves the society’s discretion to examine whether the transferee satisfies the eligibility criteria laid down in the Act, the rules and the bye-laws. The society can refuse transfer if the proposed transferee does not meet those conditions. ... The society cannot keep the estate of a deceased member in a state of suspension. ... The society has no discretion in this regard and is bound to admit Respondent No.3 as a member. ... Bhadrashete, learned Advocate for the petitioner #....
This provision deals with eligibility criteria. It does not deal with adjudication of disputes regarding illegal entries. It does not authorise the Registrar to create membership or substitute one member for another. ... —The committee of a society shall remove from the register of its members the name of a person who has ceased to be a member or who stands disqualified by or under the provisions of this Act [or the rules made thereunder] for being the member or continuing to be the member#HL_....
The predecessor-in-title of the Respondent Nos. 6 and 7 being the tenants in respect of Flat No. 7 fulfilled the essential eligibility criteria to become a member of the society (R4). Mr. ... also intimate the name of the person who would be the member of the society. ... the applicant shall be deemed to have been admitted as a member of such society. ... Yet, the decision whether to admit a person as a member of the society has to ....
In other words, the new society replaces the developer as the member of the larger, land-owning or parent society. ... Section 22 of the MCS Act, read with Section 154B-5, expressly allows one co-operative society to become a member of another co-operative society. This legal provision itself answers the objection and makes it clear that there is no legal bar to one society being a member of another. ... Such registration does not disturb the ownersh....
As already pointed out, the defendant Society has already denied / disputed the eligibility criteria canvassed by the plaintiffs. Admittedly, the plaintiffs have not claimed any declaratory relief that they are eligible to become the members of the defendant Society. ... society, that bye-law would be operative against him and no person, or aspiring member, can be heard to say that he will not be bound by that law which prescribes a qualification for his membership.” ... As rightly contended by the lear....
Viewed from that angle it has to be held that the moment a member of a society becomes ineligible to be a member of the society, that person is liable to be expelled from membership. ... ... (4) Where a member of a society becomes ineligible to continue as such, the Registrar may of his own motion or on a representation made to him by any member of the society or by the financing Bank, by an order in writing declare that he has ceased to be a #HL_ST....
member qua member would touch the business of the society. ... "Member" as used in these observations only means dealing with a member qua member and all that has been held is that R. 26 is wide enough to cover a dispute between the society and a member even though the claim does not arise against the member qua member. ... In Zamindara Bank's case, AIR 1924 Lah 418 (supra) we do not find any discussion on the ques....
Simultaneously, the Registration Officer shall intimate such member of society or individual member through authorized person or by post who is not eligible to vote as per Act/Rules/Bye-laws/Instructions. ... are enrolled as members of the Society as per their eligibility criteria coupled with the fact that society has been divided into 11 zones for election of managing committee and zones have been derived from afore five panchayats and zones comprise of hilly topography with no clea....
(i) Belongs to or is a resident of or is working in Haryana State including Chandigarh for the last one year at the time of becoming member of the society and qualifies for any of the following categories of societies.” The logical inference which can be drawn from the above clause is that a person belonging to or resident or working in Haryana including Chandigarh is eligible to become a member. A person shall be eligible for admission as a member of the Society, if he;
Society, a member or a person claiming through a member. In view of such factual position, the ratio in case of Alok Agarwal (supra) is clearly not attracted. Section 91 of the said Act contemplates a dispute touching the constitution, management or business of the Society, if the parties thereto are (inter alia)
If the total number of persons admitted to membership had not exceeded 300, then the question of voluntarily resigning just before election does not arise. We have to therefore turn to definition under Section 2(xv) that defines members thus :- The Senior Counsel would state that it is not merely a person who fulfills the eligibility criteria for membership that will be treated as a member but the Section requires a conjoint application of another requirement, namely, of such a person, having to be admitted to membership. "member" means a person who fulfills the eligibility criteri....
"member" means a person who fulfills the eligibility criteria for becoming a member of a Society, as specified in the Act and has been admitted as a member of the Society in accordance with its Bye-laws." If the total number of persons admitted to membership had not exceeded 300, then the question of voluntarily resigning just before election does not arise. We have to therefore turn to definition under Section 2(xv) that defines members thus :- The Senior Counsel would state that it is not merely a person who fulfills the eligibility criteria for membership that will be tr....
44. Section 15 lays down the qualification for person to be a member of the society. Chapter VII deals with audit, inquiry, surcharge and inspection of the record of the society, while sections 55 and 56 of the said Act deal with the determination of disputes between the members and the societies by the bureaucrat (IAS) Registrar to be appointed by the Government. Chapter IX deals with the winding up of the Cooperative Societies while Chapter X provides the mechanism of the execution of the award, decrees, orders and attachment of property before award by the Registrar.
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
