When a Defendant Denies the Signature on a Cheque, Who Must Prove It Was Actually Drawn?
One of the most frequently litigated questions in cheque dishonour cases is deceptively simple: when the accused denies that the signature on the cheque is theirs, who has to prove the cheque? The answer determines whether a complaint under the survives or fails, and it turns on the careful distinction between proving execution and rebutting .
The Short Answer
When the defendant or accused denies the signature, the initial burden of proving that the cheque was falls squarely on the complainant. The accused is not required to prove a negative — that they did not sign or draw the cheque. However, once the complainant establishes a , the burden of rebutting the under of the Negotiable Instruments Act shifts to the accused.
Why the Complainant Must First Prove the Drawing of the Cheque
For a successful prosecution under , the complainant must allege and prove that the cheque was drawn or executed by the accused. Although the Act does not define the word drawn, courts have equated it with the execution or making of the instrument. As one decision puts it, in the absence of an allegation and proof that the cheque was drawn by the accused, a conviction under cannot stand. 2022 0 Supreme(Raj) 2384
This fact can be established by direct or circumstantial evidence from a person who can vouchsafe for the truth of the facts in issue. 2022 0 Supreme(Raj) 2384
Crucially, mere possession of the cheque is not enough. The fact that the cheque produced in court came from the complainant's possession alone will not prove execution — no law permits a court to presume that a cheque produced and marked in evidence was handed over or delivered to the complainant by the accused. 2022 0 Supreme(Raj) 2384
Signature versus Execution — A Distinction That Decides Cases
Courts have increasingly drawn a sharp line between a signature and execution:
- Execution requires both of the cheque with intent to create an operative instrument.
- If the accused denies the signature itself, the complainant must first prove the authenticity of the signature before the presumptions under Sections 118(a) and 139 can be invoked.
- If the signature is admitted but execution is denied, the court must examine the basis for that denial before presumptions attach. 2026 Supreme(Online)(Ker) 48516 and 2026 Supreme(Online)(Ker) 48740
In one recovery suit, the appellate court allowed the appeal and dismissed the suit because, although a signature appeared on the cheque, the plaintiff's evidence regarding the transaction and was inadequate — the trial court had wrongly conflated signature with execution. 2026 Supreme(Online)(Ker) 48516
What Happens Once the Signature Is Established
If the signature is admitted or proved, the legal landscape changes dramatically:
- Under Section 118, presumptions of consideration and that the holder is a arise until the contrary is proved — but only after execution is established. 1998 0 Supreme(Ker) 155
- Under , once the signature on a cheque is established, the court presumes the cheque was received for the , shifting the burden to the accused to prove otherwise. 2025 0 Supreme(Chh) 17 and 2023 0 Supreme(HP) 507
In one case, an appellate court set aside an acquittal because the trial court wrongly required the complainant to prove the existence of the debt, holding that the under places the burden on the accused to rebut it. 2023 0 Supreme(HP) 507
The Accused's Standard of Proof — Preponderance, Not Certainty
The accused rebutting the presumption is not expected to discharge an unduly high standard of proof. The applicable standard is a . Unless a probable defense is raised, the complainant is not mandatorily required to prove the source of funds in the first instance. 2025 0 Supreme(MP) 1049
The accused must bring on record facts or material — for example, that the cheque was stolen, misused from blank signed cheques left with another person, or that no debt existed. 2025 0 Supreme(MP) 1049 and 2026 Supreme(Online)(Ker) 48740 Courts have emphasized that as the law places this burden on the accused, the accused must be given a fair opportunity to adduce rebuttal evidence, including the right to have disputed signatures compared by a handwriting expert under . 2022 0 Supreme(MP) 1252 and 2023 0 Supreme(HP) 509
Practical Consequences When Signature Is Disputed
- If the complainant has no eyewitness to the drawing of the cheque, they may rely on circumstantial evidence or a handwriting expert to prove authorship of the disputed signature. 2022 0 Supreme(Raj) 2384
- Where the complainant fails to lead any evidence to prove that a denied signature belongs to the accused, acquittal is likely — one appeal against acquittal was dismissed precisely because the complainant never got the disputed signatures proved. 2023 0 Supreme(All) 2142
- Conversely, an accused who denies the signature but takes no steps to compare it with admitted signatures does so at their peril; courts have confirmed convictions where no expert comparison was sought. 2016 0 Supreme(Mad) 2881
- In civil suits based on cheques, an acquittal in the criminal proceedings does not bar the civil claim — but the plaintiff must still independently discharge the by a . 2026 Supreme(Online)(Ker) 48516 and 2017 Supreme(Online)(Gau) 133
Key Takeaways
- The complainant always bears the initial burden of proving that the cheque was drawn, signed, and delivered by the accused — this burden never shifts.
- A denied signature blocks the under until authenticity is proved.
- Once execution is proved or admitted, presumptions arise, and the accused must rebut them by a — not by proving a negative beyond reasonable doubt.
- Both sides have evidentiary tools: the complainant can use handwriting experts and circumstantial evidence; the accused has a .
This article is intended as general legal information based on judicial precedents and may not apply to the specific facts of your case, so outcomes can vary with individual circumstances.
#Section138 #ChequeDishonour #NegotiableInstrumentsAct #BurdenOfProof #ChequeBounceCase