High Court of Karnataka
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE MANJULA CHELLUR & THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE S.N. SATYANARAYANA
T. Venkatesh Reddy, Bangalore & Others
Versus
The State of Karnataka by its Secretary to Department of Housing and Urban Department, Bangalore & Others
Writ Appeal Nos.4772-4811 of 2003 in W.Ps. 40156-67 of 2003 & 41771-792 of 2002, C/W Writ Appeal Nos. 263 of 2008 & 5137-97 of 2011
Decided On : 12-10-2011
1. These two batch of writ appeals are filed by two sets of persons challenging the acquisition of approximately an extent of about 60 acres of land under various survey numbers situated in Devarachikkanahalli and Bilekanahalli Villages, Bangalore South Taluk, Bangalore District. The appellants in W.A.Nos.4772-800/2011 were petitioners before the learned Single Judge in W.P.Nos.40150-167/2002 and W.P.Nos.41771-792/2002. They are land owners of various survey numbers of Devarachikkanahalli and Bilekanahalli Village. They filed aforesaid writ petitions through their General Power of Attorney Holder, namely, the Managing Director and Executive Director of M/s. Addi Housing and Industries Private Limited, who had subsequently acquired interest in the said lands. The petitions in W.P.Nos.40150-167/2002 and W.P.Nos.41771-792/2002 were disposed off by common order dated 10.4.2003. The said common order was also passed in respect of another set of writ petitions in W.P.Nos.31726-727/2002. However, petitioners in the said batch have not challenged the order of dismissal of said petitions.
2. So far as appellants in W.A.No.263/2008 and 5137-5197/2011 are subsequent purchasers of sites formed in aforesaid survey numbers by M/s. Addi Housing and Industrial Limited by securing Power of Attorney through the land owners, namely, the appellants in the other batch of appeals. In both batch of writ petitions the challenge is to preliminary and final notifications respectively dated 6.8.1988 and 3.11.1990 for acquisition of the lands in question.
3. The fact that a large extent of land was notified under Section 17 of the BDA Act vide preliminary notification dated 6.8.1988 Gazetted on 15.12.1988 in respect of lands situated in Devarachikkanahalli and Bilekanahalli villages for formation of BTM IV stage layout of BDA is not in dispute. It is also not in dispute that subsequently, final notification was issued to a lesser extent of land on 3.11.1990 which was Gazetted on 20.11.1990. Thereafter, possession of said lands were taken from time to time under the relevant provisions of the BDA Act is also not in dispute. It is further not in dispute that subsequent to the issuance of final notification, the Power of Attorney Holders of appellants/land lords, namely, M/s. Addi Housing and Industrial Ltd., and its Directors entered into an agreement with the land owners for purchase of nearly an extent of 60 acres of land which were under acquisition for formation of a private layout thereon. In that behalf, they secured the General Power of Attorney from said land owners during the period 1992-94 i.e., subsequent to preliminary and final notifications being issued for acquisition of the lands in question.
4. Thereafter, it is stated that aforesaid company formed a layout thereon. It also formulated a scheme for sale of sites formed on the aforesaid lands i.e., by registering prospective purchasers as members of the said company and by receiving the value of the site from each one of them in 30 installments at Rs.5,000/-p.m., sold the sites formed therein to the appellants in the second batch of writ appeals and others.
5. It is further not in dispute that the company, namely, M/s. Addi Housing and Industrial Limited was aware of the acquisition proceedings of the lands in question and preliminary and final notification being issued way back in 1988 and 1990 itself. The records also disclose that several attempts were made by them by approaching the Government to seek denotification of the aforesaid lands. It is also not in dispute that several orders were also passed by Chief Ministers of various Governments at different point of time recommending denotification of aforesaid lands. However, the same has not fructified in passing an order denotifying the said lands. Having failed in their attempt the Developer of the aforesaid land, namely, M/s. Addi Housing and Industrial Limited initiated the proceedings challenging the acquisition of lan
Zahira Habibullah Sheikh (5) and another Vs. State of Gujarat & Others
Banda Development Authority Band Vs. Moti Lal Agarwal & Others
Bandu Ramaswamy & Others Vs. BDA & Others
Girnar Traders Vs. State of Maharashtra & Others
Girnar Traders Vs. State of Maharashtra & Others
Girnar Traders (3) Vs. State of Maharashtra & Others
K.K. Poonacha Vs. State of Karnataka & Others
Offshore Holdings Pvt. Ltd., Vs. B.D.A. & Others, (2011) 3 SCC 139 Para 34, 56
The Amritsar Improvement Trust etc., vs. Baldev Inder Singh & Others etc.
State of Karnataka Vs. Gokula Education Foundation, Bangalore & Others
Khub Chand & Others Vs. State of Rajasthan & Others
Bahulal Badnaprasad Varma vs. Surat Municipal Corporation & Others
State of Gujrat & Others Vs. Parshothamdas Ramdas Patel & Others
Bhavnagar University Vs. Palitana Sugar Mills (P) Ltd., & Others
Chairman, Indore Vikas Pradhikaran Vs. Pure Industrial Coke & Chemicals Ltd. & Others
Padma Sundra Rao (Dead) & others Vs. State of T.N. & Others
B.E.M.L. Employees House Building Cooperative Society Ltd. Vs. State of Karnataka & Others
Devender Singh & Others Vs. State of Punjab & Others
Smt. Somavanti & Others Vs. The State of Punjab & Others
Alka Gupta Vs. Narender Kumar Gupta
Reliance Energy Ltd. & Another vs. Maharashtra State Road Development Corporation Ltd. & Others
Hansraj H. Jain vs. State of Maharashtra & Others
Bhikubhai Vithlabhai Patel and others vs. State of Gujarat & Another
AIR 1994 SC 1918 Para 173 & 174
Carona Ltd. vs. Parvathy Swaminathan & Sons
Bajranglal Shivachandrai Ruia vs. Shahikant Ruia & Others
Ramachandra Murailal Bhattad & Others vs. State of Maharashtra & Others
SupremeToday
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.