( 1 ) BY this appeal under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent, the appellant ("ongc" for short) has challenged the judgement dated 15/16. 2. 1999 of the learned Single Judge of this Court, whereby, after an elaborate discussion, reliefs as under were granted to the workmen concerned represented by the respondent trade union herein:"15. The upshot of the aforesaid adjudication is that this Court finds that the impugned award dated 6th June, 1994 passed by the Industrial Tribunal (Central) at Vadodara, is required to be modified and the same is hereby modified as under: (1) The relief will not be restricted only to those workmen whose names appear in the Schedule to the affidavit at Exh. 48 which was filed by the ONGC before the Industrial Tribunal in the Complaint (ITC) 5 of 1993, but it will be available to all the employees who fulfil the requirements of completion of 240 days or more and the minimum qualifications under the ONGC (Recruitment and Promotion) Regulations, 1980 in accordance with the relevant Certified Standing Orders and in case they fulfil these requirements, all of them shall be considered at par with regular employees for the benefits which are give