IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
J.B. PARDIWALA, J.
Ravani Ceramics - Appellant
Versus
Marshal MFG. & Exports - Respondent
R/First Appeal No. 3281 of 2017
Decided On : 25-06-2018
(A) Civil Procedure Code, 1908 – Order VII Rule 11(c) – Order VII Rule 11(c) of C.P.C. will be applicable only in those cases wherein insufficient stamp is paid – If no stamp at all is paid, then suit is liable to be dismissed under Section 4 of Gujarat Court Fees Act, 2004 – Even if suit is dismissed under Section 4 of Gujarat Court Fees Act, 2004, same will amount to rejection of plaint and order in that regard will be a decree and same will be appealable. (Para 38)
(B) Civil Procedure Code, 1908 – Sections 148 and 149 – Section 148 of Code is a general provision and Section 149 thereof is special – First application praying for time to pay court fees should be in terms of Section 149 of Code – Once Court grants time for payment of court fees within period specified thereafter, it is permissible to extend same by Court in exercise of its power under Section 148 of Code – Appeal allowed. (Paras 38 and 39)
J.B. PARDIWALA, J.
1. This First Appeal under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 is at the instance of the original plaintiff and is directed against the judgment and order passed by the additional Senior Civil Judge, Morbi dated 26th July, 2017 below Exhibit : 23 in Special Civil Suit No. 23 of 2016.
2. The facts giving rise to this First Appeal may be summarised as under:
2.1 The appellant herein - original plaintiff filed a special civil suit against the respondent herein - original defendant for recovery of the outstanding amount to the tune of Rs. 11,26,104/- with interest. The relief prayed for in the special civil suit filed by the plaintiff is as under:
"1. The plaintiff has right to claim outstanding amount Rs. 11,26,104/- as per the various goods purchased by the defendants, so plaintiff urge before the Hon'ble Court to pass an order and decree against defendant to pay the outstanding amount with interest.
2. On adjudication of right to receive the amount which was paid as per the invoice and same entitled to receive from the defendant at 12% interest from May, 2013 till the date of payment.
3. The costs of this suit be awarded to plaintiff."
2.2 The suit came to be filed on 19th April, 2016. On the very same day and date, the plaintiff preferred an application under Section 149 of the C.P.C. for grant of time for payment of the requisite court fees. The application is extracted under:
"Before the Hon'ble Principal
Senior Civil Judge at Morbi.
Special Civil Suit No. 23/2016.
The above named plaintiff most respectfully submit that:
We have filed Special Civil Suit for recovery of money and hence we have to produce court fee stamp of Rs. 26,350.00, but due to unavoidable reasons, we could not produce the same. Hence, we request you to grant 30 days time for production of Court Fees Stamp Paper.
Ravani Ceramics
sd/-
Ravani Ceramics Wankaner."
Place : Morbi.
Date : 19/04/2016.
2.3 The Civil Court on the aforenoted application passed an order which reads as under:
"15 days time granted in the interest of justice."
2.4 It appears that although time was granted to the plaintiff herein for payment of the requisite court fees, yet the court fees was not paid and in such circumstances, the defendant preferred an application Exhibit : 13 to dismiss the suit. The Trial Court treated the application Exhibit : 13 filed by the defendant to be one for rejection of plaint under the provisions of Order 7 Rule 11(c) of the C.P.C.
2.5 On 19th July, 2017, the plaintiff herein filed his reply Exhibit : 14 to the application filed by the defendant Exhibit : 13 for dismissing the suit for non-payment of the court fees. The reply of the plaintiff Exhibit : 14 is extracted hereunder:
"Subject: Objections against the application filed by the defendant to reject the suit in case of non-payment of required court fees.
It is submitted by the Advocate for the plaintiff to consider the objections against the application filed by the defendant to reject the suit in case of non-payment of Court Fees.
(1) Plaintiff has filed the suit to recover the dues of Rs. 11,26,104/- from the respondent. In this case, it is required to pay Court Fees of Rs. 26,350/-.
(2) In this case, plaintiff has not paid the Court fees of Rs. 26,350/- due to bona-fide mistake. Plaintiff had no intention not to pay Court Fees or to misuse the judicial process. Today, plaintiff has filed an application to grant permission to produce the Court Fee Stamp of Rs. 26,350/-.
(3) It is not true that plaintiff has falsely obtained the Order by falsely filing the suit within the limitation period, and by using vague words because, plaintiff was not able to file the suit due to not having the Court Fees. In this case, plaintiff has failed to produce the Court Fee Stamps due to bona-fide mistake.
(4) In this case, if the suit is rejected due to non-payment of court fee stamp due to bona-fide mistake, it will cause grave damage to the plaintiff. In this case, defendant has filed the reply and i
M.T. Emerald Sky vs. Reliance Industries Ltd. AIR 2007 Guj 90
P.K. Palanisamy vs. N. Arumugham and another (2009) 9 SCC 173
K. Natarajan vs. P.K. Rajasekaran (2003) 2 M.L.J. 305
Ramiah and Anr. v. R. Palaniappan and Ors. (2007) 5 MLJ 559
S.V. Arjunaraja v. P. Vasantha 2005 (5) CTC 401
V.N. Subramaniyam v. A. Nawab John and Ors. (2007) 1 MLJ 669
Buta Singh (Dead) By LRs. v. Union of India (1995) 5 SCC 284
State of Kerala v. M.K. Kunhikannan Nambiar Manjeri Manikoth
Baljinder Singh v. Rattan Singh 2008 (11) SCALE 198
Ram Sunder Ram v. Union of India and Ors. 2007 (9) SCALE 197
N. Mani v. Sangeetha Theatres and Ors. (2004) 12 SCC 278
Ram Prakash Gupta v. Rajiv Kumar Gupta and Ors. (2007) 10 SCC 59
Ganesh Prasad Ray and Anr. v. Narendra Nath Sen and Ors. AIR 1953 SC 431
Mannan Lal v. Mst. Chhotaka Bibi (Dead) by LRs. B. Sharda Shankar and Ors. (1970) 1 SCC 769
Ganapathy Hegde v. Krishnakudva
K.C. Skaria v. Govt. of State of Kerala and Anr. (2006) 2 SCC 285
SupremeToday
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.