HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA AGARTALA
Akil Kureshi, CJ.
Vinay Kumar Rai - Appellant
Versus
Union of India & Ors. - Respondents
WP(C) No. 596/2019
Decided On : 17-09-2021
JUDGMENT
The petitioner has prayed for quashing the proceedings and consequential orders passed thereon pertaining to a complaint of sexual harassment made against him by the respondent No.16. Since a final decision is yet to be taken by the department in connection with such a complaint, I would not make any observations with respect to the factual aspects. Nonetheless, a brief reference to some of the facts would be inevitable.
2. The petitioner at the relevant time was working as Deputy Inspector General in Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF, for short). The respondent No.16 (hereinafter to be referred to as the complainant) was serving as General Duty Medical Officer at the Group Centre of CRPF where the petitioner was posted. She lodged a complaint before the Director General of CRPF on 26.07.2018. In this complaint she had stated as under:
“To
The DG
CRPF, BLOCK NO1
CGO COMPLEX, LODHI ROAD
NEW DELHI-110003
SUB: Complaint.
Dear sir/madam,
With due respect and humble submission I would like to state that I Dr. NISHA TIWARI, GDMO IRLA NO- 505488 of GC CRPF AGARTALA TRIPURA joined my service as GDMO on Dated 29 November 2017.
I would like to draw your kind attention on the above subject matter.
1. As above I joined GC crpf Agartala and at that time Shri Vinay Kumar Rai, took the charge of DIG, Range Agartala as well as he also had additional charge of Group Centre, CRPF Agartala. Being a DIG of GC and as a protocol I went to call on him in his office at morning 9.30 hrs and after that I went to joined my duty but at evening 17.00 hrs without any reason he ordered a called from the control room and asked me to meet him at 17.30 hrs in his offices chamber. For which I had to met him again in his office room there he had forcefully taken my personal mobile number which I was not willing to gave him.
2. Sh Vinay Kumar Rai, DIG started to send me messages and I replied him in a formal way, but after some messages he sent me some informal messages. I stopped replying him and blocked his number.
3. The above officer started calling me in my landline number and asked irrelevant matter. I strictly replied him to talked to my senior male counterpart doctor Dr. Babul Roy posted in GC Agartala. I tried to avoid his irrelevant calls but still he used to call me forcefully in my landline number in odd hrs.
4. Not only Sh. Vinay Kumar Rai but also his wife Smt. Shalini Rai always billingsgate and threaten me.
5. My husband DR D S Mohan, (CMO-OG) is recently posted in 71 BN, Khumlung, Agartala because of spouse posting special case and he is also allotted a quarter in GC Agartala. But as 71 bn is under DIG Range Agartala Sh Vinay Kumar Rai. Being a DIG Range, Sh Vinay Kumar Rai strictly told Commandant 71 Bn not to give him out living permission and told him to make him stay in the unit campus only.
As above all this matter made me so much worried and mentally disturbed. I could not send this message to you but he should get a lesson so that he will not do such kind of behaviour with his Juniors wife. I request you madam to kindly keep this letter as confidential.
Yours sincerely
NISHA TIWARI, GDMO
GC AGARTALA.”
3. On 20.08.2018 the DIG issued an order constituting a Sector Level Complaints Committee (SLCC, for short) in terms of the provisions contained in the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 (hereinafter to be referred to as the Act of 2013). This committee consisted of one lady IPS Officer, as a Chairperson, one more lady officer also from the department, one lady member representing the NGO and a Legal Officer of the department.
4. The SLCC carried out the inquiry into the allegations of the complainant and eventually submitted a report on 07.02.2019. The contents of the report read as under:
“Please refer Directorate Order No.C.IV-03/2018-Vig dated 20/08/2019 and amendment issued vide order of even no. dtd 6/2/2019 2. Vide above mentioned order, a SLCC was constituted by the Directorate to look into th
Union of India and others vs. B.V. Gopinath (2014) 1 SCC 351
The expansive definition of sexual harassment under the Act includes various unwelcome behaviors, and procedural delays do not invalidate complaints or inquiries.
The Central Complaints Committee's findings on sexual harassment claims were upheld, emphasizing the importance of thorough inquiry and the principle of preponderance of probabilities in disciplinary....
The judgment establishes the application of The Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 in addressing workplace sexual harassment and emphasizes the ....
A person who participates in the enquiry proceedings without objection cannot challenge the constitution of the Committee after the result goes against them, and may not have an alternative efficacio....
: Disciplinary Proceeding – Inordinate delay on part of Ministry of Home Affairs in deciding representation of petitioner defeats equity.
The court established that disciplinary action under Section 14 of the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace Act requires a finding of malicious intent or knowledge of falsity, which was not presen....
The court emphasized that procedural safeguards and principles of natural justice must be strictly adhered to in disciplinary inquiries against probationers, including the right to be heard and to cr....
The main legal point established is that the Presiding Officer of the Internal Complaints Committee must be a higher level woman officer in accordance with Section 4(2)(a) of the Sexual Harassment of....
Once allegation of sexual assault never came to be proved, mere omission, if any, on the part of the petitioner to render written apology to respondent No.3 may not be reason to initiate disciplinary....
The main legal point established in the judgment is the illegality of the suspension order and the lack of statutory force in the committee for summary trial due to non-compliance with the relevant l....
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.