2025 MarsdenLR 4860
HIGH COURT MALAYA TAIPING
VETHRI VEL YAMAPLAY – Appellant
Versus
PP – Respondent
[Criminal Appeal No: AB-41S-2-01/2024]
Important Points
Subject
Criminal Law - Traffic Offences
Act Referred
Headnote
(B) Burden of Proof - The prosecution needs to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused was driving under the influence, which was not sufficiently established in this case due to the lack of preserved evidence. (Paras 12, 27, 39)
(C) Appeal Procedure - A court will uphold findings of a trial judge unless serious errors of fact or law are evident. (Para 15)
Facts of the case:
The Appellant caused a fatal accident while driving under the influence, resulting in the deaths of four family members and severe injuries to one child. Initial charges were amended based on insufficient evidence for the previous charges. (Paras 1, 6, 8)
Findings of Court:
The Court concluded that while the evidence was adequate for reckless driving, the evidence for intoxication lacked necessary preservation. Thus, the charges were amended from s 44(1)(b) to s 41(1), leading to a conviction for reckless driving resulting in death. (Paras 12, 39)
Issues: Whether the prosecution sufficiently proved all elements of the original charges and whether the appeal court should interfere with the lower court's decision. (Paras 5, 49)
Ratio Decidendi: The court established that reckless driving was proven through witness testimonies and evidence, yet the prosecution’s proof of intoxication fell short due to procedural errors regarding blood analysis. (Paras 32, 39)
Result: Appeal allowed in part; conviction upheld under s 41(1) with amended sentence. (Para 49)
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. a conviction was confirmed but clarified. (Para 1 , 2 , 4) |
| 2. fatal accident involved multiple victims. (Para 3 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11) |
| 3. appellant's arguments raised reasonable doubts. (Para 12 , 30) |
| 4. court analyzed evidence and judicial standards. (Para 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 19 , 20 , 22) |
| 5. conviction modified to align with evidence. (Para 32 , 39 , 43) |
| 6. sentence imposed to reflect public interest. (Para 44) |
[1] This Grounds of Judgment is prepared in respect of an appeal by the Public Prosecutor against the decision of this Court on 18 June 2025, whereby the Court dismissed the appeal against conviction of the Appellant, Vethri Vel A/L Yamaplay, but substituted the conviction to a lesser charge and sentenced him accordingly. The Court had found the Appellant guilty convicted him of four (4) offences under s 41(1) of the Road Transport Act 1987 [Act 333] ("the Act") instead. He was sentenced to 8 years' imprisonment from 13 June 2025 and fine of RM20,000.00 in default of which he would be imprisoned for a period of three (3) months for each charge and his driving licence was suspended for three (3) years and endorsed accordingly, in accordance with the provision of the said section.
[2] The Appellant has not filed any appeal as yet against the Court's decisions. However, this Grounds of Judgment covers the reasons for the convictions and not just on sentence.
Background
[3] The Appellant was originally charged for 2 offences punishable under s 44(1) of the Act which read as follows:
Pertuduhan pertama
Bahawa kamu pada 13 February 2020 jam lebih kurang 2220 hrs di KM 37.0 Jalan Ipoh-Kuala Kangsar, di dalam Daerah Sungai Siput (U) di negeri Perak semasa memandu m/treler bernombor pendaftaran WUA 5761 dan T/BD6993 telah mempunyai sebegitu banyak alkohol dalam badan sehingga kadar alkohol dalam darah kamu iaitu 201 miligram per 100 mililiter darah telah melebihi had yang ditetapkan dan kamu telah menyebabkan kematian
a) Mohamad Faiz bin Bakhari (920302-03-5711)
b) Muhammad Faqih Irsyad bin Mohamad Faiz (No. Sijil kelahiran DT93735)
c) Nik Ifeka binti Nik Hassan (930301-03-5866)
d) Nik Iedayu binti Nik Hassan (900121-03-5570)
Oleh itu kamu telah melakukan sebuah kesalahan di bawah s 44(1)(b) Akta Pengangkutan Jalan 1987.
HUKUMAN Apabila disabitkan hendaklah dihukum penjara selama tempoh tidak kurang daripada tiga tahun dan tidak lebih daripada sepuluh tahun dan denda tidak kurang daripada lapan ribu ringgit dan tidak lebih daripada dua puluh ribu ringgit.
Pertuduhan kedua
Bahawa kamu pada 13 February 2020 jam lebih kurang 2220 hrs di KM 37.0 Jalan Ipoh-Kuala Kangsar, di dalam Daerah Sungai Siput (U) di negeri Perak semasa memandu m/treler bernombor pendaftaran WUA 5761 dan T/BD6993 telah mempunyai sebegitu banyak alkohol dalam badan sehingga kadar alkohol dalam darah kamu iaitu 201 miligram per 100 mililiter darah telah melebihi had yang ditetapkan dan kamu telah menyebabkan kecederaan kepada Muhammad Fariz Iskandar Bin Mohamad Faiz (170104-03-0151). Oleh itu kamu telah melakukan sebuah kesalahan di bawah s 44(1)(b) Akta Pengangkutan Jalan 1987.
HUKUMAN
Apabila disabitkan hendaklah dihukum penjara selama tempoh tidak kurang daripada tiga tahun tahun dan tidak lebih daripada sepuluh tahun dan denda tidak kurang daripada lapan ribu ringgit dan tidak lebih daripada dua puluh ribu ringgit.
[4] The Sg Siput Magistrate's Court found the Appellant guilty of both charges and he was sentenced to 4 years' imprisonment and fine of RM10,000,00 in default of which one (1) year imprisonment for each charge. He was also disqualified from holding or obtaining a driving licence for 5 years. He paid the fines and was released on bail pending the appeal in the High Court.
[5] At the High Court, the appeal was heard on 28 March 2025 and 6 May 2025 and case adjourned for decision, which was delivered on 18 June 2025 after much deliberation on the issue of whether the charges under s 44(1) of the Act had been proved beyond a