Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query.....!
Analysing the retrieved Case Laws
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query.....!
Analysing the retrieved Case Laws
Scanned Judgements…!
Entitlement of Family Pension for Martyr Mother or Wife - According to Regulation 66(iv) of the Pension Regulations for the Army, Part 1 (2008), a mother or wife of a martyr is entitled to receive family pension, subject to specific conditions. The regulations specify that only one member of the family can receive the ordinary family pension at a time (Regulation 68). Typically, the wife or mother is recognized as primary dependents eligible for family pension upon the death of a service member ["Smt Abhilasha Chetan vs UOI,COAS,PCDA (P) Allahabad,Managing Director AGI New Delhi 110057,Smt Sarika Chuni W/O Late Lt Col Ashish Chetan R/o 125 … - Armed Forces Tribunal"].
Definition of Family and Dependents - The regulations define family as including the wife (lawfully married) in the case of male service personnel, or husband for female personnel, and also include mother if she is widow and has not remarried. The mother is eligible to receive pension first, and after her death, the father can be re-granted pension if applicable ["Smt Abhilasha Chetan vs UOI,COAS,PCDA (P) Allahabad,Managing Director AGI New Delhi 110057,Smt Sarika Chuni W/O Late Lt Col Ashish Chetan R/o 125 … - Armed Forces Tribunal"].
Conditions for Eligibility - The entitlement to family pension for parents (mother or father) occurs primarily when the deceased service member does not leave behind a widow or children. If a widow survives and is eligible, she typically receives the pension; the parents' entitlement is secondary and contingent upon the absence of a surviving widow or children ["Smt Abhilasha Chetan vs UOI,COAS,PCDA (P) Allahabad,Managing Director AGI New Delhi 110057,Smt Sarika Chuni W/O Late Lt Col Ashish Chetan R/o 125 … - Armed Forces Tribunal"].
Special Cases and Additional Insights - In cases where a widow has not remarried, she remains eligible for pension. Judicial or legal separation can affect eligibility, but generally, lawful marriage is the key criterion. The regulations also specify that family pension to unmarried or widowed/divorced daughters is payable after other eligible children cease to receive benefits and if no disabled child is involved ["2023 0 Supreme(Jhk) 249"].
Legal and Judicial Interpretations - Courts have upheld that lawful wives and widows are entitled to family pension, and that entitlement depends on the existence of a legal marriage and the absence of other primary beneficiaries. The regulations do not permit multiple family pensions for the same deceased, emphasizing the only one member rule ["2024 0 Supreme(J&K) 397"].
Analysis and Conclusion:Under the Pension Regulations for the Army 2008, a martyr mother or wife is entitled to receive family pension if she is the lawful, primary dependent and no other eligible member (such as a surviving widow or children) is claiming the pension. The regulations prioritize one member at a time, typically the wife or mother, depending on the circumstances. The entitlement is subject to conditions like lawful marriage, non-remarriage (for widows), and absence of other primary beneficiaries. When these conditions are met, the mother or wife of a martyr can receive family pension as per the provisions of Regulation 66(iv) and related rules ["Smt Abhilasha Chetan vs UOI,COAS,PCDA (P) Allahabad,Managing Director AGI New Delhi 110057,Smt Sarika Chuni W/O Late Lt Col Ashish Chetan R/o 125 … - Armed Forces Tribunal"], ["Smt Abhilasha Chetan vs UOI,COAS,PCDA (P) Allahabad,Managing Director AGI New Delhi 110057,Smt Sarika Chuni W/O Late Lt Col Ashish Chetan R/o 125 … - Armed Forces Tribunal"].
References:- Smt Abhilasha Chetan vs UOI,COAS,PCDA (P) Allahabad,Managing Director AGI New Delhi 110057,Smt Sarika Chuni W/O Late Lt Col Ashish Chetan R/o 125 … - Armed Forces Tribunal_AFT_OA_24032021: Para 66(iv), Regulations 68 & 70, 110.- Smt Abhilasha Chetan vs UOI,COAS,PCDA (P) Allahabad,Managing Director AGI New Delhi 110057,Smt Sarika Chuni W/O Late Lt Col Ashish Chetan R/o 125 … - Armed Forces Tribunal_HC_CGHC010094032017: Rules 66, definition of family, eligibility conditions.- 2023 0 Supreme(Jhk) 249: Conditions for family pension for widowed/divorced daughters.- 2024 0 Supreme(J&K) 397: Legal interpretations on entitlement of lawful wives and judicially separated wives.
Losing a loved one in military service is a profound tragedy, and the question of who receives the often arises amid grief and family disputes. According to the , who is entitled to receive the pension of a martyr – mother or wife? This issue frequently leads to legal battles, as dependents seek financial support meant to honor the sacrifice of army personnel.
In this post, we break down the regulations, hierarchy of entitlement, court precedents, and exceptions. While this provides general insights, consult a legal expert for personalized advice, as individual cases may vary.
The , govern family pensions for dependents of deceased soldiers, including martyrs. These rules establish a clear to ensure orderly distribution without division among claimants. outlines this hierarchy, prioritizing immediate family members who typically depend most on the soldier's income. 2004 0 Supreme(Del) 796
Key definition from the regulations: The term 'family' under includes (1) wife in the case of male service personnel or husband in the case of female service personnel lawfully married... This places the spouse at the forefront.
Smt. Girija Devi Upadhyay vs Smt. Sudha Upadhyay
2021 Supreme(Online)(CHH) 93The regulations specify a strict sequence for entitlement:
The holds primary entitlement. Courts have upheld that family pensions cannot be divided among heirs. The receives the entire amount, including benefits from the Scheme, excluding others like the mother. 2004 0 Supreme(Del) 796 2008 0 Supreme(Gau) 210
Mother's claim arises only if no or eligible children exist. Dependency on the deceased does not override the 's absolute right, unless the is disqualified (e.g., remarriage). 2007 0 Supreme(MP) 149 2018 0 Supreme(Mad) 2724
In one case, the court emphasized: under , it is the wife/ alone, if she is alive, who is entitled to draw both the and other benefits. 2007 0 Supreme(Gau) 593
Indian courts consistently affirm this hierarchy:
's Paramount Claim: A legally married wife, as nominee, has the first and paramount charge upon the . Compromise decrees attempting to share benefits with others (e.g., father) are void under the , and . 2007 0 Supreme(Gau) 593
No Division Allowed: The does not permit splitting between mother and . The , as , gets all benefits exclusively. 2004 0 Supreme(Del) 800
Parents' Limited Rights: Parents do not qualify if higher-priority dependents exist, per .
…
These rulings underscore that pensions are , not divisible estates. Delays in claims can invoke doctrines like (law aids the vigilant, not the sleeping). 2021 0 Supreme(P&H) 105
While the typically prevails, exceptions may apply:
's Disqualification: Remarriage ends her entitlement, potentially shifting to the mother. 2009 0 Supreme(Ker) 678
Personnel: If death occurs in ',' may not qualify under new rules. 2016 4 Supreme 59
Dual Pensions: Widows may claim from multiple sources (e.g., Army and other boards), as affirmed in cases adopting policies. 2024 0 Supreme(HP) 133
Nominations Override?: Statutory entitlement trumps unilateral nominations excluding the spouse. remains a right of the legally wedded wife. 2025 0 Supreme(All) 2894
Other contexts, like disability pensions, highlight liberal interpretations for battle casualties but do not alter hierarchy. 2024 0 Supreme(Ker) 805
Pensions cannot be withheld without due process, reinforcing claimants' rights. 2024 0 Supreme(UK) 99
Facing a dispute? Consider these steps:
If no , mothers should assert claims promptly, supported by regulations like .
…
Under the , the is generally entitled to the full of a martyr, with the mother fifth in line and eligible only in her absence. Courts reinforce this, prohibiting division and prioritizing statutory hierarchy over dependency arguments. Exceptions like remarriage or special service statuses may open doors for others, but vigilance is key.
Key Takeaways:- > Children > Father > Mother in priority. 2004 0 Supreme(Del) 796- No splitting pensions; full amount to top claimant.- Dependency doesn't trump hierarchy.- Act quickly to avoid dismissal on delay.
This overview draws from regulations and precedents like 2004 0 Supreme(Del) 796 2008 0 Supreme(Gau) 210 2007 0 Supreme(MP) 149 2018 0 Supreme(Mad) 2724 2016 4 Supreme 59 2009 0 Supreme(Ker) 678. For specific cases, professional legal counsel is essential – this is not advice tailored to your situation.
#ArmyPension #MartyrPension #FamilyPension
of para 66(iv) of the Pension Regulations for the Army, Part 1(2008). ... The respondent No.5 also submits that the applicant does not quality for the grant of pension to parents as per para 70 of the Pension Regulations for the Army, Part-1(2008) and para 110 contained in the Pension Regulations fo....
The Defence Services Regulations, Pension Regulations for the Army Part-I of 2008 provides in Rules-66, the definition of family, which shows that family for the purpose of regulation was consist (1) wife in the case male service personnel or husband in the case of female service personnel lawfully married ... It is submitted that the Army regulations ....
The Defence Services Regulations, Pension Regulations for the Army Part-I of 2008 provides in Rules-66, the definition of family, which shows that family for the purpose of regulation was consist (1) wife in the case male service personnel or husband in the case of female service personnel lawfully married ... It is submitted that the Army regulations ....
Learned C.G.C. further submits that ordinarily, family pension to unmarried daughters above 25 years of age, widowed/divorced daughters, is payable only after the other eligible children below the age of 25 years cease to be eligible to receive family pension and there is no disabled child to receive ... It is further submitted that pension was granted to the deceased serviceman vide Controller of Defence....
The petitioners now claim to be legal heirs of the widow of the deceased and in the year 2017 they served the legal notice claiming that they are entitled to get the land and financial assistance as per the Central/State policies to the Army Shaheed(Martyr). ... Surjit Kaur(mother of the petitioners) was in receipt of family pension of Rs.62.00 per month and her yearly income from land and other sources w....
The AFT having regard to the rival stand of the parties and the rule position obtaining on the subject came to the conclusion that respondent No.3 being a legally wedded wife of Sepoy Sunny Ram was entitled to family pension under Rule 75(a) of Pension Regulations for the Army, Vol.I (2008) read with ... Lawful married wife and also judicially separate....
The Tribunal made reference to Regulation 102(b) of the Pension Regulations for the Army, 2008 (for short, the ‘Regulations’) and found that the restoration of war injury pension, on repayment of compensation already received became impermissible only when the compensation received is in lieu of war ... However, as the respondent had already availed lumpsum compensation for the disabilit....
Authority under Regulation 8 of Pension Regulations for the Army, (2008). ... Regulation 104 of Pension Regulations for the Army, Part-II (2008), on which heavy reliance has been placed by learned counsel for the petitioner, is reproduced below for ready reference : “SUSPENSION DIS-CONTINUANCE OR WITH-HOLDING OF PENSION UNDER #HL_STAR....
After his superannuation from the respondent-Board, he continued to receive his pension from the Army also as well from the respondents-Board. 3. The husband of the petitioner died on 22.03.2008. ... The grievance of the petitioner is that after the death of her husband, family pension has not been paid to her by the respondent on the ground that the petitioner is entitled to r....
Sub-Rule (4) of Rule 7 provides who shall be entitled to receive the pension in the event the deceased employee had two wives. ... He passed away on 29.11.2019, therefore, his wife (petitioner herein) became entitled for family pension. The petitioner (wife) moved an application requesting for sanction of family pension. ... is entitled#HL_EN....
Regulation 173 of the Pension Regulations for the Army, 1961, reads as under: “173. 7. Pension Regulations for Army, 1961, have now been substituted by Pension Regulations for the Army, 2008. The grant of pensionary awards to personnel of the Defence Security Corps shall be governed by the same Regulations as are applicable to Personnel Below Officer Rank of the Army, except where they are inconsistent with the provisions of the Regulations in this chapter.” Pension....
Thus, it is found that the mother being placed in the last position cannot claim precedence over the wife, the first defendant, with reference to the receipt of the family pension and equally also cannot claim parity in the receipt of the family pension on the same lines as that of the wife viz., the first defendant. Though it is provided under the Pension Regulations For The Army 1961 (Part-I) that the mother is also one of the eligible members to receive the family pension, however....
The answering respondents also fairly concede that under Clauses 216 and 217 of the Pension Regulations for Army, 1961, it is the wife/widow alone, if she is alive, who is entitled to draw both the family pension and other benefits in respect of the deceased. Before proceeding further, it may at this stage be appropriate to note that from Annexure-R-1 annexed to the affidavit-in-opposition of the answering respondents, it is obvious that one of the civil suits, namely, Origin....
( 9 ) THE questions which arise for consideration in the present writ petition may be set out as hereunder :- I. Whether the Army Group Insurance Scheme permits division of the admissible Group Insurance between a mother and widow of a deceased soldier. Whether the Pension Regulations for the army, 1961 permit division of the ordinary family pension between a mother and widow of a deceased soldier.
Whether the Army Group Insurance Scheme permits division of the admissible Group Insurance between a mother and widow of a deceased soldier. ( 9 ) THE questions which arise for consideration in the present writ petition may be set out as hereunder :- I. Whether the Pension Regulations for the Army, 1961 permit division of the ordinary family pension between a mother and widow of a deceased soldier.
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
