Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query..!
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query..!
Scanned Judgements…!
The role of nominee directors or officials in corporate settings is also clarified as being that of a trustee or representative, not an owner, with responsibilities and liabilities distinguished accordingly ["Mr. P.T. Kalaiselvan vs Deputy Director General of - Madras"] ["RANJANA RAJAGOPALAN Vs LT. GOVERNOR OF DELHI & ORS. - Delhi"] ["Kanarath Payattiyath Balraj VS Raja Arora - Delhi"].
Analysis and Conclusion:
References:- ["Senior Manager, Syndicate Bank VS Soudambika Ravindran - Consumer"]- ["K. S. Chandrasekar VS Chancellor University of Kerala - Kerala"]- ["K. S. CHANDRASEKAR VS CHANCELLOR, UNIVERSITY OF KERALA - Kerala"]- ["Shakti Yezdani VS Jayanand Jayant Salgaonkar - Supreme Court"]- ["R.Saraswathi vs The Government of Tamil Nadu - Madras"]- ["Raj Lakshmi Mishra VS Chairman-Cum-Managing Director, Canara Bank - Patna"]- ["Pothumulla Kankanamge Pathma Ranathunga vs Commissioner General of Labour (Acting) and 4 others. - Court Of Appeal"]- ["Mr. P.T. Kalaiselvan vs Deputy Director General of - Madras"]- ["RANJANA RAJAGOPALAN Vs LT. GOVERNOR OF DELHI & ORS. - Delhi"]- ["Kanarath Payattiyath Balraj VS Raja Arora - Delhi"]- ["Ayushi Deepak Mishra vs Bank of India - Central Information Commission"]- ["Veera Reddy Laxminarasimha Reddy vs Union Bank of India - Central Information Commission"]
In the realm of corporate governance, insurance policies, bank deposits, and succession matters, the role of a nominee often sparks confusion. What exactly is the current position of a nominee? Does nomination grant absolute ownership, or is it something more limited? This blog post delves into the Indian legal framework, drawing from judicial precedents and statutes to clarify that a nominee typically functions as a trustee or agent, holding assets for the benefit of legal heirs rather than claiming beneficial ownership.
Understanding this distinction is crucial for individuals, families, and businesses to avoid disputes over estates, shares, or policy proceeds. While this provides general insights, consult a legal professional for advice tailored to your situation.
A nominee is generally a person designated to receive assets, funds, or benefits upon the death of the account holder, policyholder, or shareholder. Common contexts include bank accounts, provident funds, insurance policies, national savings certificates, and shares held in demat accounts. However, nomination is not a will or transfer of ownership—it's merely an administrative mechanism to facilitate payment or transfer to a trusted individual temporarily. Rajeshbabu, S/O.Rajendran vs Muralikrishanan, S/O.Late Mayadevi - 2025 0 Supreme(Ker) 2312
As courts have consistently held, nomination is an act of naming or designating a person to receive benefits, not an act of transferring ownership or beneficial interest. Rajeshbabu, S/O.Rajendran vs Muralikrishanan, S/O.Late Mayadevi - 2025 0 Supreme(Ker) 2312Niadar VS Delhi Administration - 1988 0 Supreme(SC) 635
The prevailing judicial stance in India is clear: a nominee acts as a trustee or agent of the depositor or legal owner, managing assets for the rightful legal heirs under succession laws. The nominee does not acquire absolute or beneficial ownership merely through nomination. Rajeshbabu, S/O.Rajendran vs Muralikrishanan, S/O.Late Mayadevi - 2025 0 Supreme(Ker) 2312
In national savings certificates, though Section 6 of the Government Savings Certificates Act uses different phrasing from Section 39 of the Insurance Act, the effect remains identical: amounts paid to nominees form part of the deceased's estate and devolve to entitled persons, not the nominee as owner. Vishin N. Khanchandani VS Vidya Lachmandas Khanchandani - 2000 5 Supreme 574
Indian courts, including the Supreme Court, have reinforced this position across statutes:
Further, in succession certificate cases under Section 372 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, nominees hold proceeds for and on behalf of all the sharers and are bound to distribute to other legal heirs. The court in one case dismissed an appeal, applying precedents like Shakti Yezdani vs. Jayanand Jayant Salgaonkar, emphasizing shared entitlement. T. Nagendra Setty, S/o. Late T. Thippanna Setty VS T. Vishwanath Setty, S/o. T. Thippanna Setty - 2024 Supreme(Kar) 58
The 2015 amendment to Section 39 abolished the distinction between 'beneficiary nominee' and 'collector nominee.' Even post-amendment, nominees can only collect and hold sums assured in trust, subject to legal heirs' claims under personal laws. In a writ petition, the court directed payment to Class-I heirs (widow and son) over the nominee (deceased's brother), stating the nominee holds funds subject to the claims made by the legal heirs. K. R. Sakthi Murugeswari VS Divisional Manager Divisional Office, Life Insurance Corporation of India, Tirunelveli - 2023 Supreme(Mad) 3139
Sub-sections 7-10 of Section 39 clarify this custodial role, ensuring insurers are discharged upon payment to nominees, but heirs' rights persist.
Under the Government Savings Certificates Act, payments to nominees become estate property devolving by law. Similar interpretations apply to the Indian Succession Act. Vishin N. Khanchandani VS Vidya Lachmandas Khanchandani - 2000 5 Supreme 574Shipra Sengupta VS Mridul Sengupta - 2009 6 Supreme 199
While the trustee principle dominates, nuances exist:
Shares and Depositories Act, 1996: Sections 9 and 11 grant nominees superior rights upon death, potentially overriding testamentary dispositions. Once others are excluded, the nominee gains full share rights, akin to Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act for housing society shares. Harsha Nitin Kokate v. Saraswat Co-op. Bank Ltd. - 2010 Supreme(Online)(Bom) 8
Sole Heirs or Testamentary Cases: If the nominee is the sole heir or via will, outcomes may differ, but mere nomination doesn't confer ownership.
These exceptions highlight context-specific applications, underscoring the need for precise legal review.
In corporate settings, nominees (e.g., director nominees) hold fiduciary roles without ownership. Policies must stress succession compliance to prevent challenges.
In summary, the current position of a nominee in Indian law is that of a fiduciary, ensuring smooth asset transfer while safeguarding heirs' rights. This framework promotes equity but demands awareness to navigate effectively.
This post is for informational purposes only and not legal advice. Laws evolve; seek expert counsel. References drawn from cited judgments.
References1. Vishin N. Khanchandani VS Vidya Lachmandas Khanchandani - 2000 5 Supreme 574: Government Savings Certificates Act nominee position.2. Rajeshbabu, S/O.Rajendran vs Muralikrishanan, S/O.Late Mayadevi - 2025 0 Supreme(Ker) 2312: Nominee as trustee under Hindu Marriage Act context.3. Shipra Sengupta VS Mridul Sengupta - 2009 6 Supreme 199: No beneficial interest in insurance/gratuity/PF.4. Niadar VS Delhi Administration - 1988 0 Supreme(SC) 635: Nomination authorizes receipt, not appropriation.5. K. R. Sakthi Murugeswari VS Divisional Manager Divisional Office, Life Insurance Corporation of India, Tirunelveli - 2023 Supreme(Mad) 3139: Insurance Act 2015 amendment analysis.6. T. Nagendra Setty, S/o. Late T. Thippanna Setty VS T. Vishwanath Setty, S/o. T. Thippanna Setty - 2024 Supreme(Kar) 58: Nominee bound to share with heirs.7. Harsha Nitin Kokate v. Saraswat Co-op. Bank Ltd. - 2010 Supreme(Online)(Bom) 8: Depositories Act nominee superiority in shares.
#NomineeRights, #LegalHeirsIndia, #SuccessionLaw
In view of the clear legal position, it is made abundantly clear that the amount in any head can be received by the nominee, but the amount can be claimed by the heirs of the deceased in accordance with law of succession governing them. ... In the light of the above legal position, we have to test whether there was any deficiency in service on the part of the appellant in not releasing the fixed deposit amount to the respondent, who is the nominee of the deceased. 17. ... When the factual position is r....
However, on 04.08.2022, the nominee declined to accept. ... The Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary defines “nominate” as: “Nominate: to formally suggest that somebody should be chosen for an important role, prize, position, etc.” In The Law Lexicon by P. ... Now let us ponder over the scope of the term “nominations” and “nominee.” ... On 05.08.2022, the Chancellor issued Ext.P4 notification, constituting the “Search-cum-Selection Committee” consisting of his nominee and the nominee of the University ....
However, on 04.08.2022, the nominee declined to accept. ... The Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dictionary defines “nominate” as: “Nominate: to formally suggest that somebody should be chosen for an important role, prize, position, etc.” In The Law Lexicon by P. ... Now let us ponder over the scope of the term “nominations” and “nominee.” ... Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dictionary of Current English has explained the meaning of the term “arbitrary” as: “Of an action, a decision, a rule, etc. not seeming to be based on a reason....
This position continues even after the amendment made to the Insurance Act in the year 2015. ... To properly understand the position of law, it will be appropriate to extract Sub Sections 7 to 10 of Section 39 of the Insurance Act, 1938, hereunder: “39. Nomination by Policy holder:- (1)... ... 5) I submit that since there are two claims for this policy amount i.c. one by the 3rd Respondent and the other by the writ petitioner as referred above, we are not in a position to take a decis....
In contrast, one must note that ownership of the securities is not granted to the nominee nor there is any distinct legislative move to revamp the extant position of law, with respect to the same. 22. ... Once all other persons are excluded and only the nominee becomes entitled under the statutory provision to have all the rights in the shares, none other can have it. Further, section 9.11 of the Depositories Act 1996 makes the nominee's position superior to even a testamentary disposition. ... Before we proceed any furt....
Further, it is a settled position of law that the last recorded nomination would take precedence over the earlier nomination recorded. ... form in the month of May 2015, whereby he has shown the name of the 3rd respondent as nominee. ... The first and second respondents further contended that since, as per the records, the 3rd respondent has been nominated by the deceased employee/petitioner’s son, as nominee during his lifetime, it is only the said nominee who is entitled to receive the benefits and for the said ... Sin....
a job or position, etc; someone nominated to or for a job or position, etc; a person or organization appointed to act on behalf of another, especially in order to keep the identity of the first secret; some one whose life an annuity or lease depends. ... There are judgments which would hold that nominee has got a preferential right over the legal heirs. Therefore, in order to obviate such difference of opinion, it is necessary that the Court has to find out who is a nominee. ... In fact, the nominee may....
Once all other persons are excluded and only the nominee becomes entitled under the statutory provision to have all the rights in the shares none other can have it. Further S.9.11 of the Depositories Act 1996 makes the nominee's position superior to even a testamentary disposition. ... It may be mentioned that the position under S.30 of the Maharashtra Co - operative Societies Act is similar for nominees in respect of shares in a Housing Society. ... Once the amount under the Policy is paid to the nominee, the ....
In view of the settled legal position that nomination alone does not confer any exclusive beneficial interest on the nominee, the amount so received are to be distributed according to Hindu Succession Act, 1956. ... It is admitted position that the deceased subscriber did not file fresh nomination after his marriage. ... However, it has been informed that her claim as a nominee will not be considered by the concerned authority because after marriage she was not nominated as a nominee by the deceased emp....
The Petitioner contends that her claim is based on the premise that she is the wife of the deceased and had been a nominee to receive the EPF benefits. This position is established by a reply the Petitioner has received on a Right to Information request made by her. ... In view of what has transpired as stated above this position of the Petitioner cannot be sustained and it is not tenable. ... Suppression of material facts It is the contention of the Respondents that the Petitioner cannot be a nominee as the nomination ....
As already mentioned, no documents are available indicating the nature of permission granted. The opening up of accounting and related services, can be linked to reciprocal opening up by developed countries. (g) Additional powers required by ICAI to curb the malpractices – What is the current position of international trade in accounting and related services?
After conducting the interview, the results of the interview shall be filed before this Court by 25th April, 2016....." We request the Lieutinant Governor to nominate a suitable member within a week hence. In view of the above said position, the Lieutinant Governor shall nominate someone else as a nominee so that the Selection Committee can meet.
In view of the above said position, the Lieutenant Governor shall nominate someone else as a nominee so that the Selection Committee can meet. After conducting the interview, the results of the interview shall be filed before this Court by 25th April, 2016.” We request the Lieutenant Governor to nominate a suitable member within a week hence.
In view of the above said position, the Lieutenant Governor shall nominate someone else as a nominee so that the Selection Committee can meet. We request the Lieutenant Governor to nominate a suitable member within a week hence.
No person shall be eligible for appointment as a nominee of a Board of Nominees, unless he, (a) is holding or has held a judicial office not lower in rank than that of Senior Civil Judge, or (b) has practiced as an Advocate, Pleader or Vakil for not less than ten years, or (c) is enrolled as an Advocate or holds a degree or other qualification in law of any University established by law or of any other authority which entitles him to be enrolled as an Advocate, and either, - (i) is a Joint Registrar of Cooperative Societies, or (ii) has held office not lower in rank than that of Deputy Regis....
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
