Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query..!
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query..!
Scanned Judgements…!
Potential for Misappropriation and Corruption Several sources highlight the risk of mediators and negotiators being involved in criminal activities, such as aiding in misappropriation of funds or accepting illegal commissions. For example, the funds were misappropriated by some of the officers and further... mediators also obtained 18% commission ["B. Veeranjaneyulu VS State of A. P. - Andhra Pradesh"], ["B.Veeranjaneyulu vs The State of A.P. - Andhra Pradesh"]. This raises ethical concerns regarding undue influence, corruption, and the integrity of mediators involved in such transactions.
Questionable Conduct in Legal and Investigative Processes Instances where mediators' reports are relied upon without transparency or proper procedural compliance raise ethical issues. For instance, the order is passed relying on mediators report... which has not seen the light of day ["Aseena Peera vs The State of Andhra Pradesh - Andhra Pradesh"]. Additionally, mediators sometimes participate in procedures like vehicle checks or property recoveries without proper legal authorization, which can compromise fairness and impartiality.
Bias and Lack of Impartiality Several cases mention mediators who do not support the prosecution or the recovery process, such as the mediators did not support the factum of recovery of the stolen property ["G.BUCHAIAH AND ANOTHER vs THE STATE - Telangana"], ["G.BUCHAIAH AND ANOTHER vs THE STATE - Telangana"]. This suggests potential bias or partiality that can undermine the neutrality expected from mediators.
Training and Ethical Standards The importance of proper training is emphasized, with a minimum of 40 hours of structured training mandated to ensure mediators develop skills like effective communication and impartial dispute management ["D.A.Prabakar vs The Secretary to Government - Madras"]. Adequate training is crucial to uphold ethical standards and prevent misconduct.
Role of Mediators in Sensitive Situations Mediators are involved in delicate processes such as crime investigations, property disputes, and negotiations involving sensitive information. Their conduct in such contexts must adhere to ethical principles of confidentiality, impartiality, and honesty to maintain trust and justice.
The provided sources collectively underscore significant ethical concerns surrounding mediators, negotiators, and support persons, primarily focusing on issues of corruption, procedural integrity, bias, and the need for rigorous training. The involvement of mediators in criminal activities like facilitating misappropriation or accepting illegal commissions highlights the necessity for strict oversight and ethical standards. Furthermore, reliance on mediators' reports without transparency can jeopardize fairness and due process. To address these issues, establishing comprehensive training programs, clear ethical guidelines, and accountability mechanisms is essential to ensure mediators act impartially and uphold the integrity of dispute resolution processes.
References:- ["SARFARAZ KHAN vs STATE OF ODISHA - Orissa"]- ["Aseena Peera vs The State of Andhra Pradesh - Andhra Pradesh"]- ["B. Veeranjaneyulu VS State of A. P. - Andhra Pradesh"]- ["B.Veeranjaneyulu vs The State of A.P. - Andhra Pradesh"]- ["LIEW SWEE YEE vs METRO HOMES SDN BHD - High Court"]- ["PREETHA S vs VITHU MOHAN - Kerala"]- ["THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. vs SRI NISHANTA TAMULI AND 2 ORS - Gauhati"]- ["D.A.Prabakar vs The Secretary to Government - Madras"]- ["G.BUCHAIAH AND ANOTHER vs THE STATE - Telangana"]- ["Ramavath Nanu vs State of A.P. rep.by Public Prosecutor - Telangana"]- ["G.BUCHAIAH AND ANOTHER vs THE STATE - Telangana"]- ["G.BUCHAIAH AND ANOTHER vs THE STATE - Telangana"]- ["JANA DURGA PRASAD vs THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH - Andhra Pradesh"]
In the realm of alternative dispute resolution (ADR), mediators, negotiators, and support persons play pivotal roles in resolving conflicts outside traditional courtrooms. But what are the ethical concerns of mediators, negotiators and support persons? This question often arises amid growing reliance on mediation in commercial, family, and other disputes. While mediation promises efficiency and confidentiality, potential ethical pitfalls like impartiality, conflicts of interest, and confidentiality breaches loom large.
This post examines Indian judicial perspectives, drawing from key court documents and rulings. Note: This is general information based on reviewed cases and not specific legal advice. Consult a qualified lawyer for your situation.
Mediation frequently precedes arbitration or litigation. For instance, service agreements may designate senior management as initial negotiators or mediators. One clause states: the issue will be first re referred to the senior management of both the Parties for resolution who shall act as the negotiators/mediators for 30 days before arbitration Cravants Media Private Limited vs Jharkhand State Co-operative Milk Producers Federation Ltd. - Delhi (2021). Courts also appoint experts, such as senior advocates, as co-mediators. The Supreme Court appointed Mr. Sriram Panchu, Senior Advocate ... and Mr. Niranjan Bhat, Senior Advocate ... to be the Co-mediators, recognizing them as two of the foremost experts in mediation in India State of Assam VS Union of India - 2010 0 Supreme(SC) 1543.
These roles extend to family disputes, where mediation reports guide custody decisions, and even criminal contexts. In criminal investigations, mediators (often local panchas) witness confessions and seizures. Police may take the same mediators to Kondaguntur or other sites based on confessions Gandumenu Siva VS State of Andhra Pradesh, represented by its Public Prosecutor - 2014 Supreme(AP) 358. Similarly, under procedures for inspections, independent and respectable persons of that locality have to be taken as mediators for reports Sai Krishna Pidathala VS State of Andhra Pradesh - 2021 Supreme(AP) 331.
Yet, across these scenarios, courts validate these processes without flagging ethical lapses in mediator conduct.
Confidentiality underpins mediation ethics. Section 75 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and Delhi High Court rules protect proceedings. One ruling clarifies: Confidentiality of mediation proceedings – Absolute where court acts as adjudicator – But not when court acts in the capacity of parens patriae Perry Kansagra VS Smriti Madan Kansagra - 2019 0 Supreme(SC) 174. In custody cases, child welfare trumps strict confidentiality; courts consider counselors' reports as the paramount principle is the best interest of the child.
No infirmity was found in a High Court committee's counselor appointment, with reports taken on record Perry Kansagra VS Smriti Madan Kansagra - 2019 0 Supreme(SC) 174. This exception highlights how context shapes ethical boundaries—absolute in commercial mediation but flexible in family matters prioritizing welfare.
In seizures, mediator reports must detail assets accurately, but lapses (e.g., missing vehicle details) lead to procedural critiques, not ethical ones against mediators Sai Krishna Pidathala VS State of Andhra Pradesh - 2021 Supreme(AP) 331.
Surprisingly, reviewed documents reveal no explicit ethical concerns for mediators, negotiators, or support persons. Mediation appears in appointments State of Assam VS Union of India - 2010 0 Supreme(SC) 1543, failed attempts Madhumita Bhainsora VS Ramesh Dhar - 2025 0 Supreme(SC) 1462, and processes, but without scrutiny on impartiality, bias, or conflicts.
Ethical discussions elsewhere are tangential:- For counsel summoned as witnesses: ethical considerations, and legal principles related to summoning the counsel, requiring judicial caution and observing inhibitions when counsel testifies Yovas VS Immanueal - 1995 0 Supreme(Ker) 99.- Parental moral and ethical values in custody, unrelated to mediators Manju VS Shivprasad - 2024 0 Supreme(Del) 84.
Even in trusts, mediators resolved leadership disputes without ethical flags Ratneshwar s/o. Trimbakappa Kore VS Manmathappa s/o. Pandaba Lokhande - 2014 Supreme(Bom) 1601. Fiduciary relationships emphasize trust, and reliance, the fiduciary’s superior power, but mediation isn't framed this way UNION OF INDIA THR. DIRECTOR, MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL, PG & PENSION VS CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSION & SHRI P. D. KHANDELWAL - 2009 Supreme(Del) 1283.
Beyond civil ADR, mediators serve procedural roles. In counterfeit currency cases, police used mediators for discoveries, with courts upholding evidence Gandumenu Siva VS State of Andhra Pradesh, represented by its Public Prosecutor - 2014 Supreme(AP) 358. Excise seizures require mediator reports, but invalid ones (e.g., using officials instead of independents) prompt returns of seized vehicles as illegal and unjust, violating rights—not due to mediator ethics, but procedural flaws Sai Krishna Pidathala VS State of Andhra Pradesh - 2021 Supreme(AP) 331.
In parole, rules benefit prisoners liberally, but no mediator ethics arise Narayan Ram VS State of Rajasthan - 2012 Supreme(Raj) 918. Customs refunds discuss known duties, tangentially noting negotiators without ethics Sony India VS Commissioner of Customs, New Delhi - 2014 Supreme(Del) 1106. Properties of Cosmic Negotiators appear in execution, neutrally AJOY BHUSAN DEB AND ORS vs COSMIC NEGOTIATORS LTD AND ORS.
These cases show mediators as neutral witnesses, with concerns procedural rather than ethical.
While mediator ethics remain unaddressed, parallels exist:- Counsel-Witness Rules: Evidence Act S.118, Bar Council Rules, CPC Order XVI Rule 1(2) impose duties Yovas VS Immanueal - 1995 0 Supreme(Ker) 99.- Fiduciary Duties: Inherent trust obligations UNION OF INDIA THR. DIRECTOR, MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL, PG & PENSION VS CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSION & SHRI P. D. KHANDELWAL - 2009 Supreme(Del) 1283.- Parens Patriae: Overrides confidentiality for child welfare Perry Kansagra VS Smriti Madan Kansagra - 2019 0 Supreme(SC) 174.
No similar codes bind mediators explicitly in these documents, suggesting reliance on general principles like impartiality and competence.
Recommendations (general guidance):- Select experienced, impartial mediators (e.g., senior advocates) State of Assam VS Union of India - 2010 0 Supreme(SC) 1543.- Document processes clearly to avoid challenges.- In family disputes, balance confidentiality with welfare.- Differentiate from counsel ethics Yovas VS Immanueal - 1995 0 Supreme(Ker) 99.
Ethical concerns of mediators, negotiators, and support persons appear minimal in Indian jurisprudence, with emphasis on effective processes over codified ethics. Confidentiality and proper appointments dominate, with exceptions for public interest. As ADR grows, expect evolving standards—stay informed via professional bodies.
This analysis draws from specific rulings; outcomes vary by facts. Seek tailored advice.
The informant has got back his money, the accused persons do not have to face criminal proceedings and valuable time of the court has been saved. 11. ... The first requirement is the existence of adequate infrastructural facilities and, what is more important, availability of trained and skilled Mediators. ... This must be undertaken on a regular and urgent basis, particularly keeping in mind when there is a dearth of trained mediators. There is a need to have a dedicated bar for mediation. ... Another area of concern is the availability....
It goes beyond the requirement for lawyers to act in accordance with their ethical obligations and merely acting honestly or in accordance with law and court rules. ... Collector, who is quasi judicial authority and responsible officer in the District hierarchy and learned Assistant Government Pleader appearing for Civil Supplies with more greater responsibility, brought on record the real facts by placing Telugu typed Panchanama, filling up blanks dated 16.08.2019 to support ... Turning to the facts of present case, for one reason or the other, State fair....
It was also found that the funds were misappropriated by some of the officers and further between the vendor of the medicines and the health department officers, there were negotiators and mediators who helped the authorities in doing this criminal act and these mediators also obtained 18% commission
It was also found that the funds were misappropriated by some of the officers and further between the vendor of the medicines and the health department officers, there were negotiators and mediators who helped the authorities in doing this criminal act and these mediators also obtained 18% commission
In return we will offer the following support to the partner 1) Licence support as in Malaysia each office need a licence, we source and employ a licence holder here (monthly licence fee absorb by the branch around RM 1,500-2,000 per month). .....". In Matad Sdn Bhd v. ... PW2 and PW6 testified that all they need was the booking form for commission to be paid to the negotiators. ... The developers would pay the commission to the defendant and the defendant in turn would pay the commission directly to the negotiators. Ba....
Therefore, when we issue any order, we will have to ensure the necessary balance between the afore two concers.
All existing Mediators including the Mediators who have undergone 40 Hours Mediation Training recently shall be involved in this Campaign and matters shall be marked to them. 7. ... TIME LINE 1st JULY TO 31st JULY- Case Identification, Information to parties and referral to Mediators.
The learned counsel further submits that the authorities to sanction funds and depute the mediators are the first and third respondents herein. The petitioner has sent a representation to them on 24.10.2024, however no steps have been taken by them so far. ... Therefore, the Mediation Training Manual of India mandates a minimum of 40 hours of structured training, to equip the mediators with skills such as effective communication, decision-making and the management of disputes in a balanced and impartial manner.
When A.1 made confession, police carried the same mediators to Kondaguntur also and at Kondaguntur when the arrested persons revealed some information with regard to material at Tanuku, police proceeded with same mediators to Tanuku also. ... On the basis of confession of arrested persons, police and mediators have proceeded to the house of P.W.1. According to the confession of the arrested persons, A.5 is residing in the house of P.W.1 and there, the preparation process is being done.....
By the said notification, the Versus the properties of the judgment-debtor namely Cosmic Negotiators
As per the procedure provided for conducting the inspection and seizure and for drafting mediators report, the independent and respectable persons of that locality have to be taken as mediators. This Court noticed from the mediators report that the persons, who acted as mediators at the time of drafting the mediators report, are no other than the Village Revenue Officer and Village Revenue Assistant. The particulars of the car (i.e.) (1) Registration Number; (2) Colour of the car; (3) Chasis Number of the car; (4) Engine Number of the car, etc., are not mentioned in the med....
The resolution Nos. 4 and 5 were to the effect that the original Constitution was not to be changed, but the membership was to be increased. In this meeting some mediators successfully resolved the dispute between these two leaders.
Customs duties, properly so charged, are those which every importer knows to be leviable on the importation of goods, of course subject to any exemption which may be provided. The regime under which customs duty can be recovered concers known events and details. Several contingencies with respect to rate of duty, removal of goods, their warehousing, etc are envisioned in the scheme of the Customs Act. However, in the case of SADC, which is a levy meant to offset any advantage, there is inherent a right to refund, once the importer shows that the goods have been sold or the ....
The twin rights of "life" and "personal liberty" continue to glow even in the dark concers of a prison. Even when the convicted prisoner is serving a "term of imprisonment" or of "life imprisonment", he does have a right of consideration of his case for parole. Ralizing these twin aspects, the Rajasthan Prisoners (Release on Parole) Rules, 1958 (`the Rules', for short), were created as a piece of social beneficial legislation for the benefit of the large number of convicted prisoners. 5. Although incarceration of a person necessarily implies deprivation of his fundamental r....
In a fiduciary relationship, the principal emphasis is on trust, and reliance, the fiduciary‘s superior power and corresponding dependence of the beneficiary on the fiduciary. It is legal acceptance that there are ethical or moral relationships or duties in relationships which create rights and obligations. In a fiduciary relationship, the principal emphasis is on trust, and reliance, the fiduciary‘s superior power and corresponding dependence of the beneficiary on the fiduciary. Fiduciary relationships may be formal, informal, voluntary or involuntary. Fiduciary relationsh....
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
