When Some Defendants Contest and Others Remain Ex Parte: Can the Still Be Set Aside?
It is a common situation in multi-defendant civil suits: some defendants appear and contest the case, while others are set ex parte. After a full trial, the court decrees the suit. Later, one of the defendants who had been set ex parte files an application — within the period of limitation — to set aside the . The plaintiff then objects, arguing that since some defendants contested the matter and the suit was decided on merits, the ex parte set-aside petition should be rejected. Do the judicial precedents support the plaintiff's objection, or does the ex parte defendant still have a remedy?
The Short Answer From Judicial Precedents
The consistent position emerging from the case law is that the petition to set aside an is not barred merely because some other defendants . The first proviso to empowers the court to set aside the entire decree — including the portion against contesting defendants — if the decree is indivisible and cannot be set aside against the ex parte defendant alone 2008 7 Supreme 22 and 2012 0 Supreme(Cal) 300.
How Order IX Rule 13 CPC Works
The General Rule
Ordinarily, an application under Order IX Rule 13 can be made only by the defendant against whom the decree was passed ex parte. If allowed, the decree is set aside only as against that defendant, and the suit is revived qua that defendant alone.
The First Proviso: Setting Aside the Entire Decree
The first proviso broadens the court's power:
Provided that where the decree is of such a nature that it cannot be set aside as against such defendant only it may be set aside as against all or any of the other defendants also. 2002 4 Supreme 30
This means that where the relief granted is joint and inseparable — for example, a decree for partition of joint family properties or a decree operating on the same property — the court may set aside the decree against all defendants, including those who appeared and contested 2008 7 Supreme 22.
Why the Plaintiff's Objection Fails
The Word Decree Means Decree in General
A key interpretive question is whether the word decree in the first proviso refers only to an . The in held that the Legislature deliberately omitted the expression ex parte before decree in the first proviso, while using in the second proviso and the explanation. This shows the proviso was intended to apply to a decree in general 2008 7 Supreme 22.
Two Inconsistent Decrees Cannot Coexist
Courts have reasoned that allowing a against contesting defendants to stand, while restoring the suit against the ex parte defendant, could produce conflicting outcomes in the same suit. As one decision put it, , and there is no impediment to in toto provided it is 2012 0 Supreme(Cal) 300.
The Proviso Would Otherwise Be Infructuous
If the proviso applied only where the decree was ex parte against the other defendants too, it would be practically meaningless — because in that scenario those defendants would already have their own independent right to seek setting aside. The proviso exists precisely for the situation where other defendants contested and succeeded on merits 2008 7 Supreme 22.
Timing: The Proviso Is Considered When the Is Set Aside
The applicability of the first proviso must be examined by the court at the time of , not at a later stage after restoration 2022 0 Supreme(SC) 591. The court must, at that point, assess the nature of the reliefs claimed and decide whether the decree is divisible or indivisible.
The Nature of the Decree: Ex Parte or On Merits?
A related question arises when the trial court records evidence and decrees the suit after contest by some defendants. Courts have held that where a defendant was set ex parte before the trial against them commenced, the decree remains an as far as that defendant is concerned, even though it is a for the others. Such a defendant remains entitled to maintain an application under Order IX Rule 13, and delay in filing may be condoned under on a justice-oriented view of .
Limitations and Cautions
- Divisible decrees: If the relief against the ex parte defendant is separable from the relief against contesting defendants, the court may set aside the decree only against the applicant 2008 7 Supreme 22.
- Timing: The proviso is considered at the stage of , not afterwards 2022 0 Supreme(SC) 591.
- Prior appeal: Under the explanation to Order IX Rule 13, no application lies if an appeal against the has been disposed of on any ground other than withdrawal 2002 4 Supreme 30.
- Limitation and diligence: Applications must be filed within the statutory period. Courts have consistently refused condonation where the delay was inordinate, unexplained, or reflected a lackadaisical attitude — for instance, delays of 1600 days without proper explanation were rejected, since the law of limitation is founded on public policy and no premium can be given for negligence 2008 0 Supreme(Mad) 3467.
Practical Takeaways for Defendants
- Act promptly: File the Order IX Rule 13 application within limitation, and if there is delay, explain it with a genuine, documented .
- Plead indivisibility: If the decree is joint and inseparable, specifically urge the court to invoke the first proviso and set aside the decree against all defendants, including those who contested.
- Anticipate the plaintiff's objection: The contention that the petition is barred because co-defendants is not a valid legal bar.
Conclusion
Judicial precedents generally support the ex parte defendant: contesting co-defendants do not extinguish the right to seek setting aside of an under Order IX Rule 13 CPC. Where the decree is , the court may exercise its discretion under the first proviso to set aside the entire decree, ensuring that one suit does not end in inconsistent decrees. Plaintiffs, on their part, can resist only on genuine grounds — divisibility of the decree, prior appellate disposal, or want of and limitation. Because outcomes turn on the specific facts of each case, parties should treat this as general information and seek tailored advice for their own proceedings.
#ExParteDecree #OrderIXRule13 #CPC #CivilProcedure #SetAsideDecree