SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Can a Legatee Be Substituted as Legal Representative of a Deceased Appellant Despite Adverse Pleas?

When a Deceased Appellant Faces Adverse Pleas: Who May Continue the Appeal as Legal Representative?

When a party to an appeal dies during its pendency, the proceedings do not simply vanish — they either abate or continue through a legal representative. A recurring and practical question arises: can a person be substituted as the legal representative of a deceased appellant when a plea or defence has already been taken against the deceased appellant, and does the court have to decide anything before allowing that substitution? The short answer generally given by courts is twofold: yes, a natural successor or legatee may be substituted despite an adverse plea on record — but only after the court first determines, under Order 22 Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, who actually represents the deceased's estate.

Why the Question of Adverse Pleas Does Not Bar Substitution

An objection sometimes raised is that because a defence or plea was pleaded against the deceased appellant, the deceased's interest was already contested, and therefore no one should be permitted to step into the deceased's shoes. Courts have generally rejected this as a ground to refuse substitution altogether.

A legatee or natural successor can be brought on record to prosecute the appeal from the stage at which the deceased died. In one such matter, applicants who described themselves as legatees of the deceased appellant Shakuntla Mathur sought substitution to continue a first appeal; the court observed that the application, filed promptly after the death, showed an intention to represent the estate, and that legatees under a will can be treated as having semblance of interest in pursuing the proceeding of appeal 2022 0 Supreme(Raj) 2337.

The adverse plea on record does not change this position, because the substituted representative is not free to fight a different battle. Once brought on record, the legal representative takes the place of and is bound by pleadings of their predecessors and cannot raise fresh defences based on individual rights that are hostile to the deceased's claim in the suit 2022 0 Supreme(Raj) 2337. The representative continues the same litigation on the same pleadings — nothing more, and nothing less.

The Mandatory First Step: Determination Under Order 22 Rule 5 CPC

Where the identity of the legal representative is disputed, the court cannot skip ahead. Order 22 Rule 5 provides that where a question arises as to whether any person is or is not the legal representative of a deceased plaintiff or defendant, such question shall be determined by the Court 2022 0 Supreme(Raj) 2337.

This determination is not optional, and it cannot be deferred. Courts have repeatedly held that the legal representation question shall first be decided before substantive issues are taken up, and that a court cannot also postpone the decision as to who is the legal representative of the deceased respondent, for being decided along with the appeal on merits 2022 0 Supreme(HP) 187 and 2024 0 Supreme(Ori) 532. Where an appellate court or tribunal allowed two rival sets of claimants — one propounding a will, the other claiming by intestacy — to be substituted simultaneously without deciding anything, the order was set aside as patently illegal and the matter was remitted for a proper inquiry limited to who was entitled to represent the estate 2019 0 Supreme(All) 778.

Key features of this determination include:

  • It is summary in nature, conducted for the limited purpose of ascertaining who will represent the estate in the proceedings 2022 0 Supreme(Raj) 2337.
  • It must be based on evidence and proper inquiry, not conjecture or mere documents; where a court decided rival claims (one based on familial ties, another on a purported will) without allowing evidence, the order was quashed and remitted 2025 0 Supreme(Bom) 93.
  • It does not confer title. Even a person held to be the legal representative gains no adjudicated right to the deceased's property as against rival claimants 2022 0 Supreme(Raj) 2337 and 2026 Supreme(Online)(MP) 4394.
  • Where the will propounded is not duly proved, the claimant's status remains open, and the question may be referred for inquiry 2026 Supreme(Online)(Ker) 267.

Legal Heir Is Not Automatically a Legal Representative

Another frequent confusion is between the two terms. Section 2(11) CPC defines a legal representative broadly and inclusively as a person, who in law represents the estate of a deceased person, including anyone who intermeddles with the estate 2019 0 Supreme(Mad) 3026 and 2013 0 Supreme(Raj) 151. A legal heir, however, need not be a legal representative unless and until he represents the estate of the deceased person 2019 0 Supreme(Mad) 3026.

This distinction matters in practice. A claimant who was merely a Class II heir under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, and failed to show that the deceased had no Class I heirs, was not permitted to maintain a claim petition as the deceased's legal representative 2013 0 Supreme(Raj) 151. Conversely, because the definition is inclusive and wide, courts focus on estate representation rather than settling final title: where a testamentary legatee had already been substituted and natural heirs later sought impleadment, the court held that both could be brought on record for the purpose of representation without resolving the conflict between testamentary and intestate succession 2026 Supreme(Online)(MP) 4394.

Legatees, Unprobated Wills, and Continuing the Deceased's Case

A legatee under an unprobated will may generally be substituted, since an executor or legatee derives authority from the will upon the testator's death rather than from probate; absence of probate does not by itself preclude the legatee from pursuing the litigation, though a decree in favour of the legatee may await probate where the legatee's right is itself in issue 2024 0 Supreme(Ori) 532 and 2022 0 Supreme(Raj) 2337.

Where the deceased leaves no legal representative at all, the court is not helpless: it may proceed in the absence of a representative or appoint the Administrator-General, an officer of the court, or another fit person to represent the estate, and any judgment or order will bind the estate 2023 0 Supreme(Pat) 671.

Timely application also matters. Bringing a legal representative on record within the prescribed period prevents abatement of the appeal or suit in the absence of fraud or collusion 1964 0 Supreme(SC) 212.

Practical Takeaways for Parties and Counsel

  1. Apply promptly under Order 22 Rules 3/4 CPC after the death of a party; delay risks abatement.
  2. If the representative's identity is contested, insist on — or request — a determination under Order 22 Rule 5 before the appeal proceeds on merits.
  3. Demonstrate that you will represent the estate and will not set up claims or defences hostile to the deceased's interest in the litigation.
  4. Remember that a Rule 5 determination is procedural only; substantive disputes over the will or succession must be fought in appropriate proceedings.

In essence, an adverse plea taken against a deceased appellant does not disqualify a successor from substitution — but the court must first decide who the legal representative is before the appeal can move forward. This article is general information, and anyone facing a dispute over representation of a deceased party's estate may wish to consult the specific orders and statutory text applicable to their case.

#Order22Rule5CPC #LegalRepresentative #AbatementOfAppeal #CivilProcedureCode #SuccessionLaw
Chat Download
Chat Print
Chat R ALL
Landmark
Strategy
Argument
Risk
Chat Voice Bottom Icon
Chat Sent Bottom Icon
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
whatsapp-icon Back to top