Sr. No.

Particulars

Paragraph nos.

I

Introduction

1.1 to 1.10

II

Plaint

2.1 to 2.37

III

Written Statement

3.1 to 3.8

IV

Oral and Documentary Evidence led by the plaintiffs and the defendants

4.1 to 4.6

V

Applications filed by the plaintiffs and the defendants

5.1 to 5.17

VI

Issues

6.1 to 6.21

VII

Submissions of plaintiffs

A) On preliminary objections

B) On merits

7.1 to 7.25

7.26 to 7.57

VIII

Submissions of defendants

A) On preliminary objections

B) On merits

8.1 to 8.24

8.25 to 8.145

IX

Counter claim filed by defendant nos. 4 and 5 for revocation of the suit patent

9.1 to 9.76

X

Reply/submission of the plaintiffs for counter claim – revocation of the suit patent

10.1 to 10.45

XI

Analysis

A) Preliminary objections

i) for applying section 58 of the Evidence Act

ii) for not complying with section 65B of the Evidence Act, 1872

iii) to apply Order XI as per Commercial Courts Act, 2015

B) on merits

C) counter claim

11.1 to 11.9

11.10 to 11.14

11.15 to 11.19

11.20 to 11.137

11.138 to 11.151

XII

Conclusions

A) Issue No.1

B) Issue Nos.2