High Court Of Madhya Pradesh
T. N. SINGH, S. K. DUBEY, R. C. LAHOTI
RAM DAYAL - Appellant
Versus
CENTRAL NARCOTIC BUREAU - Respondents
MISC. CRI. CASE 273 Of 1992
Decided On : 09/03/1992
(ii) Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 - Sections 18,37 and 50
Prosecution for offence U/S 18 - Effect of noncompliance of section 50 - Circumstances under which the High Court or the Special Court can grant bail.
Held: Before plea raised in terms, section 50 of the Act by a person arrested in Connection with an offence under section 18 thereof is accepted and the Court reaches the conclussion that its jurisdiction to release the accused is not curbed by the "limitations" contemplated under section 37, it must address, itself to the question of bona fides of the plea and hold an enquiry in that regard. It may reject the plea if its is found to be a mere pretence; so if, it is not a case of a searching the person of the accused an of alleged recovery, in the course of such search, of the contraband substance.
(ii) Neither, High Court nor the special Court has jurisdiction to accept the plea waiving the "limitations" contemplated under section 37, without investigating its truth and validity. The Court has to reach affirmatively the tentative conclusion that the arrest and the subsequent proceedings are impugnable albit leaving open for decision in the Court of trial, the question of prejudice. We hold accordingly that Mari Appa (spura) is not correctly deicded decided and that is overuled.
(para 19)
(iii) Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 - NDPS Rules, 1985. Rule 2(c) - Chemical analysis of unlawfully possessed opium seized in Connection with an offence - Any Laboratory in the Country permissible to do the analysis - Laboratories of Neemuch and Ghazipur are for analysis of samples of lawfully cultivated and produced opium. (Para 20)
Result: Ordered accordingly.
( 1 ) THIS Reference is made by one of us (S. K. Dubey, J.) while hearing third bail application of the accused/applicant, arrested in connection with an offence under S. 8/18, The Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985, for short, the 'act', or NDPS Act. After hearing counsel, we framed following two questions which arise for our consideration in the facts and circumstances of the case : 1. If for offence under S. 18, NDPS Act, charge-sheet is filed 90 days after the arrest of the accused, whether the latter will, as of right, be entitled to get bail from High Court ? 2. Under what circumstances, the High Court or the "special Court" can grant bail under S. 37, NDPS Act, to a person accused of an offence under S. 18 of the said Act if plea is raised by the accused in terms of S. 50 of the said Act ?
( 2 ) ON 8-8-1991, the accused was apprehended while travelling in a bus with an attache case, on Agra-Bombay Road, near Shivpuri. From his possession, 5,100 gms. of opium, found kept in the attache case, was seized by the officers of the Narcotics Department. On chemical analysis at Neemuch Laboratory, the identity of the seized article has been established as opium. He has made repeated attempts in the course of last one year for release on bail.
( 3 ) BY order passed or 23-11-1991, in Misc. Cr. Case No. 1823 of 1991, his first bail application was rejected by S. K. Dubey, J. and that decision is reported as Ram Dayal Koli v. State, 1991 (2) MPJR 328. It was unsuccessfully contended house him that for non-compliance of S. 50, NDPS Act, the accused was entitled to bail and reliance was placed on this court's Indore Bench's decision in Hari Appa v. State of 1991 JLJ 193 and 415. In the decision rendered, S. K. Dubey, J. referred to another decision of this Court, of the same Bench, in Bhavarsingh v. State of M. P. , 1990 JLJ 193 and Apex Court's decision in Narcotics Control Bureau v. Kishan Lal, AIR 1991 SC 558. However, when the instant application was pressed (repeating the prayer for bail for the third time) reliance was placed on a D. B. decision of this Court rendered at the Main Seat in the case of Kalika Prasad v. State of M. P. (1992 (I) MPWN 5 : 1992 (1) Crimes 73) wherein it has been held that in a case in a which challan is not filed within sixty days of arrest, the accused becomes entitled of bail. That decision's correctness is doubted. Obviously, therefore, accused applicant's entitlement to bail is to be considered on two grounds pertaining to the effect of non-compliance of S. 50, NDPS Act and his right, if any, contemplated under S. 167 (2), Cr. P. C.
( 4 ) ARGUMENTS in this matter were heard on 3-7-1992, 14-7-1992, 24-7-1992 and finally, oral hearing was concluded on 29-7-1992 when following order was passed and counsel's prayer to file written arguments was allowed : "during the course of hearing of this Reference, we had the advantage of hearing Shri B. K. Juneja, Assistant Narcotics Commissioner who deputies in this matter for the Commissioner of Narcotics, whose office is situated in the City of Gwalior. It is a Central Government Office and the Commissioner's jurisdiction prevails over the entire country. We told Shri Juneja to file affidavit in regard to statements which are made by him today in Court before us, but would like to record briefly a few facts which we found pertinent for disposing of the Reference. For Opium, he told us, the transport-route is the Agra-Bombay Road; it comes from Punjab and Rajasthan mainly and goes to Bombay. One of the main trafficking centres is Guna in relation to the crop cultivated locally in the State and in the neighbouring State of Rajasthan. He told us further that of late, it has been discovered that in Gwalior and Guna and neighbouring areas, technical knowledge has been acquired for conversion of opium into heroin and that is dangerous because trade in heroin is highly lucrative in financial terms and it is an international trade. We c
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.