Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query!
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query!
Scanned Judgements…!
Compassionate Appointment - Eligibility and Criteria Compassionate appointment is a concession, not a right, and is subject to specific eligibility criteria, including financial conditions of the family and the immediacy of circumstances at the time of the employee's death. It must be implemented strictly in accordance with the prescribed terms and conditions ["M. Paul Mohamed Mustafa VS Managing Director, Tamil Nadu Water Supply and Drainage Board - Madras"], ["P. Rajeshkumar VS Commissioner of Industries & Director of Industry & Commerce, Department of Industries and Commerce - Madras"], ["N. Baladesh VS Chairman, The Tamil Nadu Electricity Generation and Distribution Corporation Ltd. , (TANGEDCO) - Madras"], ["K. Kesavalu VS Chairman, Chennai Port Trust, Rajaji Salai, Chennai - Madras"], ["N. Vinayagam VS Government of Tamil Nadu, Represented by Principal Secretary to Government, Higher Education Department - Madras"].
Time Limitation and Lapse of Rights The scheme cannot be extended after a significant lapse of time; delayed applications lose their immediacy, and the benefit is not applicable if the claim is made long after the death or crisis. The object of the scheme is frustrated if the appointment is granted after a long delay, emphasizing the need for prompt action ["Mehulkumar Ghanshyambhai Dahodiya VS State Of Gujarat - Gujarat"], ["P. Rajeshkumar VS Commissioner of Industries & Director of Industry & Commerce, Department of Industries and Commerce - Madras"], ["N. Baladesh VS Chairman, The Tamil Nadu Electricity Generation and Distribution Corporation Ltd. , (TANGEDCO) - Madras"], ["K. Kesavalu VS Chairman, Chennai Port Trust, Rajaji Salai, Chennai - Madras"], ["Yatrik Vinodrai Purohit VS State of Gujarat - Gujarat"].
Immediacy and Purpose of the Scheme The core purpose of compassionate appointment is to provide immediate relief to families facing sudden hardship due to the death of an employee. Delay undermines this purpose, and the scheme is designed to be exercised with a sense of urgency ["Solanki Sandipbhai Manibhai vs State Of Gujarat - Gujarat"], ["Gagan Sharma VS Secretary, Services Department Govt. of NCT of Delhi - Delhi"].
No Vested Right and Evaluation of Family’s Financial Position Compassionate appointment is not a vested right; authorities are permitted to evaluate the financial status of the family at the time of the employee's death. The claim cannot be claimed as inheritance or based on succession, and the appointment cannot be extended to heirs after retirement or superannuation ["P. Rajeshkumar VS Commissioner of Industries & Director of Industry & Commerce, Department of Industries and Commerce - Madras"], ["S. Parthasarathi VS Chairman, Chennai Port Trust, Rajaji Salai, Chennai - Madras"], ["K. Kesavalu VS Chairman, Chennai Port Trust, Rajaji Salai, Chennai - Madras"], ["N. Vinayagam VS Government of Tamil Nadu, Represented by Principal Secretary to Government, Higher Education Department - Madras"].
Alternative Compensation If the claim for compassionate appointment is denied, the petitioner may be considered for lumpsum compensation in lieu, but the fundamental object of providing immediate relief through appointment remains central ["Solanki Sandipbhai Manibhai vs State Of Gujarat - Gujarat"], ["Yatrik Vinodrai Purohit VS State of Gujarat - Gujarat"].
Analysis and ConclusionCompassionate appointment is a humanitarian concession aimed at providing immediate support to families in distress upon the death of an employee. It is governed by strict rules emphasizing promptness, financial eligibility, and adherence to prescribed procedures. Delay in application or failure to meet criteria results in the forfeiture of this benefit, reaffirming that it cannot be claimed as a vested right or through inheritance. The scheme’s primary objective is to address urgent needs, and any extension beyond the intended scope defeats its purpose. When denied, alternative remedies like lumpsum compensation may be considered, but the fundamental principle remains that compassionate appointment is a matter of discretion, not entitlement.
Losing the primary breadwinner in a family can plunge dependents into immediate financial crisis. In such heartbreaking situations, compassionate appointment offers a lifeline by providing government or public sector jobs to eligible family members. But what exactly is a compassionate appointment? Often queried as Compassionate Appiontmant (a common misspelling), this benevolent scheme under Indian law aims to alleviate sudden economic hardship faced by families of deceased or incapacitated employees. Central Bank of India VS Nitin - Supreme Court (2022)
This blog post breaks down the essentials of compassionate appointments, drawing from established legal precedents and schemes like the U.P. Recruitment of Dependants of Government Servants Dying in Harness Rules, 1974. Whether you're a dependent seeking clarity or a legal professional advising clients, understanding these provisions is crucial. Note: This is general information and not specific legal advice. Consult a qualified lawyer for your case.
Compassionate appointment is a discretionary provision allowing dependents—such as spouses, children, or siblings—of a deceased or medically incapacitated government employee to secure employment. Its core purpose is to provide immediate financial relief to families suddenly deprived of their sole breadwinner, preventing destitution. Biswanath Senapati VS State of West Bengal - Calcutta (2024)
As highlighted in judicial interpretations, Compassionate appointment is an exception to the general rule of public employment and is meant to provide minimum relief for meeting immediate hardship to save the bereaved family from sudden financial crisis. Iqbal Khan VS State of U. P. - 2022 Supreme(All) 249 It stems from pure humanitarian considerations, not as a regular recruitment channel. Iqbal Khan VS State of U. P. - 2022 Supreme(All) 249
This scheme is typically governed by department-specific rules, such as those for central or state government employees. It's not a vested right but a concession extended under strict guidelines. KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION, BANGALORE VS K. NATARAJ - Karnataka (2001)Mohd. Ashraf Gojri VS State Of J. &K. - J&K (2006)
Eligibility is rigidly defined to ensure the scheme benefits only those in genuine indigent circumstances. Key criteria include:
In one case, a petitioner's application was rejected due to a 30-year delay since the father's death, underscoring that neither there is any useful purpose to issue any positive direction after such lapses. The unauthorized appointment was deemed a nullity. Narendra Kumar Upadhyay VS State of U. P. - 2021 Supreme(All) 982
Courts have laid down foundational principles to prevent misuse:
Navigating the process correctly boosts success chances:
In a DAVP case, the CCA rejected an application after noting pension and benefits, informing: committee did not find it a fit case for recommendation. The court upheld, focusing on decision-making process, not the outcome. Minati Das(Datta) & Anr. VS Union of India & Ors. - 2010 Supreme(Gau) 676Minati Das VS Union of India - 2010 Supreme(Gau) 673
Strict rules curb arbitrariness:
Courts emphasize: Writ jurisdiction checks if the case received due consideration, not re-decides merits. Minati Das(Datta) & Anr. VS Union of India & Ors. - 2010 Supreme(Gau) 676
Applicants often face rejections for delays, insufficient proof, or scheme non-compliance. High Courts intervene if processes are arbitrary but rarely direct appointments. For instance:
Compassionate appointments play a vital role in supporting bereaved families, but success hinges on strict adherence to rules, timely action, and proven need. Schemes like those under U.P. Rules exemplify balanced humanitarianism without opening floodgates to regular employment.
Key Recommendations:- Submit applications promptly with complete documents.- Prepare for financial scrutiny; gather affidavits and proofs.- Review your department's specific scheme to sidestep pitfalls.- Seek legal aid early for representations or petitions.
References: Central Bank of India VS Nitin - Supreme Court (2022)UCO Bank (United Commercial Bank) through its General Manager VS Devi Kishan Harijan S/o Late Shri Bhikha Ram Harijan - Rajasthan (2016)Biswanath Senapati VS State of West Bengal - Calcutta (2024)Krishna Kumari VS State of Haryana - Punjab and Haryana (2012)Bharani Shakthi VS Director of School Education, Chennai - Madras (2019)VISHAL KUMAR RATHOR VS STATE OF U. P. - Allahabad (2015)KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION, BANGALORE VS K. NATARAJ - Karnataka (2001)Mohd. Ashraf Gojri VS State Of J. &K. - J&K (2006)T. Ravichandran VS The Managing Director, Chennai Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage Board - Madras (2011)PADMA PATHAK VS MANAGING DIRECTOR PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK - Allahabad (2003)HRUTHIK N. , S/O LATE NINGARAJU K. VS DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS (ADMINISTRATION) MYSURU DISTRICT, MYSURU - Karnataka (2021)Mukhtar Ahmad Rather VS State Of J. &K. - J&K (2008)Iqbal Khan VS State of U. P. - 2022 Supreme(All) 249Narendra Kumar Upadhyay VS State of U. P. - 2021 Supreme(All) 982MONIKA VS STATE OF U. P. - 2016 Supreme(All) 297Minati Das(Datta) & Anr. VS Union of India & Ors. - 2010 Supreme(Gau) 676Minati Das VS Union of India - 2010 Supreme(Gau) 673.
Disclaimer: Laws evolve; this overview is for informational purposes. Always consult professionals for tailored advice.
#CompassionateAppointment #IndianEmploymentLaw #LegalGuide
claim for compassionate appointment. ... In this case, there is a financial criteria of eligibility for compassionate appointment under the Compassionate Appointment Scheme. ... imminent circumstances, warranting an appointment on compassionate grounds. ... Scheme of compassionate appointment has to be implemented strictly in accordance with the terms and conditions stipulated. Compassionate#HL_....
claim for compassionate appointment. ... Once the long time passed by, the compassionate element stands extinguished. A family who could survive for long years would not be entitled to any compassionate benefit since compassionate benefit is not a largesse nor it is a rule in the employment. ... The delay which may have occurred for either reason would take out the element of immediacy which is sine qua non in offering the....
claim for compassionate appointment. ... In this case, there is a financial criteria of eligibility for compassionate appointment under the Compassionate Appointment Scheme. ... Compassionate appointment is a concession. Thus, cannot be claimed as a matter of right. ... The petitioner submitted an application seeking appointment on compassionate grounds on 08.06.2010. ... However, in evaluating a claim fo....
claim for compassionate appointment. ... In this case, there is a financial criteria of eligibility for compassionate appointment under the Compassionate Appointment Scheme. ... imminent circumstances, warranting an appointment on compassionate grounds. ... Scheme of compassionate appointment has to be implemented strictly in accordance with the terms and conditions stipulated. Compassionate#HL_....
claim for compassionate appointment. ... In this case, there is a financial criteria of eligibility for compassionate appointment under the Compassionate Appointment Scheme. ... However, in evaluating a claim for compassionate appointment, it is open to the authorities to evaluate the financial position of the family upon the death while in service. Compassionate appointment is not a vested right. ... No ....
Delay on the part of the authorities of the State to decide claims for compassionate appointment would no doubt frustrate the very object of a scheme of compassionate appointment. ... grant of compassionate appointment would be without any purpose whatsoever. ... It is further submitted that the petitioner in case if he is not deemed to be entitled for compassionate appointment may be granted lumpsum compensation in lieu o....
claim for compassionate appointment. ... In this case, there is a financial criteria of eligibility for compassionate appointment under the Compassionate Appointment Scheme. ... However, in evaluating a claim for compassionate appointment, it is open to the authorities to evaluate the financial position of the family upon the death while in service. Compassionate appointment is not a vested right. ... No ....
that would amount to granting compassionate appointment against the basic purpose for compassionate appointment as held by Hon’ble Supreme Court i.e. ... By way of this petition, the petitioner has prayed for compassionate appointment or lumpsum compensation in lieu of compassionate appointment as per Government Resolution dated 05.07.2011. ... 6.5 Further, considering the fact that if any direction for compassi....
to apply for compassionate appointment and Petitioner may be given liberty to lay a challenge to the policy of compassionate appointment on that score. ... Thus, there is also a compelling need to act with a sense of immediacy in matters concerning compassionate appointment because on failure to do so, the object of the scheme of compassionate would be frustrated. ... to whether a case for the grant of compassion....
claim for compassionate appointment. ... In this case, there is a financial criteria of eligibility for compassionate appointment under the Compassionate Appointment Scheme. ... imminent circumstances, warranting an appointment on compassionate grounds. ... Scheme of compassionate appointment has to be implemented strictly in accordance with the terms and conditions stipulated. Compassionate#HL_....
9. We have carefully considered the submissions of learned counsels for the parties and perused the records of the writ petition. Object and principles of Compassionate Appointment:-
Fact of the matter is that manipulation is writ apparent and petitioner has already been apprised of the fact that in case any facts are found concealed, said appointment shall ipso facto cancelled.” Object and principles of Compassionate Appointment:-
His widow also applied for compassionate appointment on 15 April 2013. The brother of the appellant had pre-deceased his mother on 3 October 2008. The appellant applied for compassionate appointment.
I am directed to refer to your application date 1.10.2002 on the subject mentioned above and to inform you that your application for compassionate appointment was placed before the duly constituted committee on Compassionate Appointment was placed before the duly constituted committee on Compassionate Appointment (CCA) of DAVP for consideration. Subject: Request for compassionate appoint-ment-reg.
Madam, I am directed to refer to your application date 1.10.2002 on the subject mentioned above and to inform you that your application for compassionate appointment was placed before the duly constituted committee on Compassionate Appointment was placed before the duly constituted committee on Compassionate Appointment (CCA) of DA VP for consideration. No.A-42011/20/03-ADMN-IV GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF INFORMATION AND BROADCASTING DIRECTORATE OF ADVERTISING AND VISUAL PUBLICITY B-BLOCK,....
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
