SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2026 MarsdenLR 188

HIGH COURT MALAYA SHAH ALAM
HELMI HAMZAH, JC
PENCHALA PROPERTIES (M) SDN BHD & ANOR – Appellant
Versus
MOHD NAZRUL IZAD MOHD ARSAD & ANOR – Respondent
[Originating Summons No: BA-24NCVC-2816-12/2025]



Important Points

A caveatable interest must be a registrable interest in the land or a claim to title. Purely monetary claims, such as reimbursement for project expenses or financial assistance, do not constitute a caveatable interest and cannot justify the lodgment of a private caveat.

Subject

Land Law - Private Caveats

Act Referred

National Land Code 1965: S.323, S.327, S.329
National Land Code (Revised 2020) Act 828: S.323, S.327, S.327(1), S.329
Rules of court 2012: O.37
Kaedah-Kaedah Tanah Selangor 2003

Headnote

(A) National Land Code (Revised 2020) Act 828 - Sections 323, 327 and 329 - Removal of private caveat - Three-stage inquiry: (i) whether the caveator has a caveatable interest in the land; (ii) whether the claim discloses a serious question meriting a full trial; and (iii) whether on the balance of convenience, it is better to maintain the caveat until trial. (Paras 5-7)

(B) Caveatable interest - To be caveatable, the interest must be an interest in the land capable of registration or a claim to title; a purely monetary entitlement, claim for compensation, or claim to the proceeds of sale does not constitute a caveatable interest. (Paras 37-39)

(C) Application for removal - An "aggrieved person" under section 327(1) is not required to have a registrable interest to qualify for the application to remove a caveat. (Para 27)

(D) Grounds for caveat - The court's consideration is limited to the grounds specified in Form 19B and the accompanying statutory declaration; grounds not listed therein cannot be considered. (Paras 29-30)

Facts of the case:
A developer of a construction project was wound up, and a liquidator was appointed. A contractor was engaged for project rehabilitation. A third party provided financial assistance for preliminary works and strata title costs. Subsequently, a private caveat was lodged on the land by a representative of the third party based on these monetary payments. The registered proprietor and the developer applied for the removal of the caveat.

Findings of Court:
The caveator failed to establish a caveatable interest as the claim was purely monetary and did not represent a registrable interest in the land. The plaintiffs were held to be aggrieved persons entitled to seek removal.

Issues: Whether the private caveat lodged by the defendants should be removed.

Ratio Decidendi: A private caveat requires a caveatable interest, which must be a proprietary or registrable interest in the land. Monetary claims for expenses or financial assistance do not confer such an interest and are insufficient to justify the maintenance of a private caveat.

Result: Application to remove the private caveat allowed with costs; damages to be assessed.

Petitioner Advocates:Kumaresun Chandrarajan,David Charles ,Respondent Advocate: Muhammad Nazrin Mohd Seth

JUDGMENT

(Removal Of Private Caveat)

Helmi Hamzah JC:

Introduction

[1] Enclosure 1 is the plaintiffs' application by way of an Originating Summons ("OS") to remove a private caveat lodged by the 1st Defendant ("D1") on behalf of the 2nd Defendant ("D2") on 22 October 2025 via presentation no 06B7137/2025 ("Private Caveat") on a piece of land registered as No hak milik GM 6252 Lot 11298 of Mukim Hulu Langat, Selangor Darul Ehsan ("Land").

Relevant Law On The National Land Code

Applicable Law: NLC 1965 Or Act 828?

[2] In this OS, the plaintiffs' application to remove the Private Caveat was made under ss 323, 327 and 329 of the National Land Code 1965 ("NLC 1965").

[3] It is important to note that NLC 1965 was superseded by the National Land Code (Revised 2020) Act 828 ("Act 828") upon its coming into force on 15 October 2020.

[4] Therefore, reference should be made to Act 828 and not NLC 1965, although ss 323, 327(1) and 329 of Act 828 and ss 323, 327(1) and 329 of NLC 1965 carry similar provisions.

Removal Of A Private Caveat: Three-Stage Inquiry

[5] In Eng Mee Yong & Ors v. Letchumanan 1979 MarsdenLR 33; [1979] 2 MLJ 212 PC, Lord Diplock explained the three-stage inquiry in a removal of private caveat application as follows:

"This is the nature of the onus that lies upon the caveator in an application by the caveatee under s 327 for removal of a caveat: he must first satisfy the court that on the evidence presented to it his claim to an interest in the property does raise a serious question to be tried: and, having done so, he must go on to show that on the balance of convenience it would be better to maintain the status quo until the trial of the action, by preventing the caveatee from disposing of his land to some third party."

[Emphasis Added]

[6] Hashim Yeop A. Sani FJ (as he then was), in delivering the decision of the Federal court in Wong Kuan Tan v. Gambut Development Sdn Bhd [1984] 1 MLRA 321; [1984] 2 MLJ 113; [1984] 1 CLJ (Rep) 441 FC, explained further about the removal of a private caveat:

"To put it more simply, the caveator in this case must first satisfy the court that he has 'caveatable interest' in the land. Only if he has such an interest can he qualify to lodge caveat under s 323(1) of the National Land Code..."

[Emphasis added]

[7] Based on the foregoing authorities, the caveator must satisfy the following three-stage inquiry:

(a) Whether the caveator has a caveatable interest in the land ("First-Stage Inquiry");

(b) If a caveatable interest is established in the First-Stage Inquiry, the court will then consider whether, based on the affidavit evidence, the claim discloses a serious question meriting a full trial ("Second-Stage Inquiry"); and

(c) Whether on the balance of convenience, the caveator can show that it would be better to maintain the private caveat until the full trial of the action ("Third-Stage Inquiry").

Issue

[8] Should the Private Caveat lodged by the defendants be removed?

Salient Facts

[9] The 1st Plaintiff ("P1") is the developer of a construction project known as 'Cadangan Membina Dan Menyiapkan 110 Unit Rumah Pangsapuri Yang Dikenali Sebagai Taman Impian Langat Yang Terletak Di Lot 11298 (GM6252), Lot 11299 (GM4372) Dan Lot 11300 (GM4273), Hulu Langat, Selangor' ("Project").

[10] P1 had financial difficulties and failed to complete the Project;

[11] On 13 July 2015, the Kuala Lumpur High court allowed Maybank Islamic Berhad's winding-up petition No: 28NCC-361-05/2015, resulting in a Winding-Up Order being made against P1.

[12] On 18 December 2017, Augustine a/l L.T.K James was appointed as the Liquidator of P1 ("Liquidator") via the Kuala Lumpur High court post-Winding-Up Order proceeding no: WA-28PW-162-10/2017.

[13] The Liquidator subsequently appointed AP Land Construction Sdn Bhd ("AP Land Construction") as the main contractor for the rehabilitation of the Project, subject to the terms of the letter of offer dated 5 July 2019 ("LO"), including cl 1.2.3, which states that AP Land Construction is responsible f



1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top